I am trying to figure out where would be the cheapest Walmart, Dillions, or the commisary. Where have you found to be the cheapest place to get groceries???
I've never heard of them. Are they in Manhattan? I just moved here :) (I lived in Junction City for 2 months a year ago.) We live on post about 10 minutes? from Trooper Gate
For us, each store has things that I get there. Dillons doubles coupons up to 1.00, and I can load e-coupons to the loyalty card, so I get what I have a coupon for there, the commissary seems to have cheaper meat, and walmart is where I get paper/household products. I like Hyvee for their meat department, esp. when we grill. Ray's depends on what they have on sale.
IMO, the commissary has the cheapest regular prices on MOST things. There are some things that are cheaper at Sam's club if you buy them in a larger quantity and they're things you use a lot of. The weekly ads make some things cheaper at the other grocery stores in town.
If you don't want to keep up on ads and figure out what thing are on sale and where, you'll have the cheapest bill if you shop at the commissary regularly. If you keep up on the sales and are willing to shop at several stores, you can save even more money doing it that way.
I think the commissary is cheaper too. I have shopped everywhere, and always spend less there. I have compared on many of the things I buy and the commissary is almost always cheaper.
I am not into wasting gas running around to different stores with sales. I just print out/ clip coupons for the stuff I buy, and head to the commissary.
I'll stick with the commy. I look at the Walmart ad, and the Hyvee ad each week and event their advertised sales often run higher than what I pay at the commy. I save fuel since I'm already on post. And I'm talking about the kind of difference that a coupon wont help.
Does walmart match the commissary prices? I thought they match anywhere. The past couple times I went in walmart I didn't have an ad to show them because it wasn't a sale item it was just normal price elsewhere and they matched it.
Overall, I shop at the commissary. My 2 week bill is much less there than it was when I lived in Manhattan or went to the JC walmart for groceries. Almost everything that we buy is cheaper there, and then I use coupons on top of that. I was at Walmart in JC the other day and figured I'd look since I was going "coupon shopping" later that day, I ended up only buying a couple bottles of herbal essence, everything else was cheaper at the commissary.
I shop at the commissary for all our groceries too (unless I just need to run and get 1 or 2 things real quick). I even get my shampoo there (herbal essence, but if I'm near dillons I'll get it there when it's $2.50 instead of almost $3.00 at the comm). Almost everything is cheaper there. I have always found Hyvee to be on the high side (for me at least) and I got sick of going from store to store and spending so much time / gas. I just stick to the commissary; we already spend enough money as it is, the last thing we want is to spend more lol.
I shop for most of my groceries at the commissary. Then some things that the commy doesnt have I get at Walmart. I went to Hyvee for the first time tonight and they are more expensive. They were selling a box of cereal for double what walmart was selling it for. They have some neat stuff in there though but its not cheap...maybe with coupons but I dont do that.
Personally, I can't stand shopping at the commissary for many reasons. The only thing I have my husband pick up is dog food on his way home, because that is the most convienant place to buy what she eats.
I am big on customer service and the few times I have been to this one, people have been rude or just plain dumb and that is only the employees! Also, my kids are all school aged, so going in there and hearing little ones throw tantrums drives me nuts! Brings a whole new meaning to military "brats". Only saw it twice at Walmart in JC said thing was, both were military families too!
I went to Hyvee for the first time tonight and they are more expensive. They were selling a box of cereal for double what walmart was selling it for. They have some neat stuff in there though but its not cheap Oh yeah, I definitely agree!!
I am big on customer service and the few times I have been to this one, people have been rude or just plain dumb and that is only the employees! Yeah, unfortunately A LOT of the employees are quite rude (and some of the people that shop there have never heard of the words "EXCUSE ME"), but sad to say I just have to get passed it with our budget :-/
I didn't read though all the post. For the most part commissary is cheaper if you like the name brand stuff. I can't do off brand like walmart or hyvee. There are very few items i will do those brands other wise it has to be named brand which in that case commissary seems to be cheaper for us. I use to shop at walmart when we 1st moved here and lived off post. I was spending about 2-250 for me and my husband every 2 weeks. My daughter wasn't even 1 yet so i wasn't really buying much food for her and my son wasn't born yet. Now that they are 4 and 5 years old and i shop at the commissary i spend 150-200(for family of 4). But like i said i won't do store brand stuff. I know someone that does commissary for meat becuase it's cheaper and hyvee for the rest. I went with her this pay day she spent 40 at commissary on meat and a few other things and 90 at hyvee. Why becuase she buys the cheapest brand of food there is. At hyvee she either buys the country fair or the hyvee brand which are the cheapest brands at hyvee. Her total obviously between the 2 placeses was 130 for a family of 5 at the moment. But even last pay day when he was home they only spent 150 at hyvee. ANd that was buying everything there. But like i said they don't care about brand they will buy the cheapest brand to save money. NOT ME!!
Rays apple market and hyvee it just depends on what you have for coupons and the time of week what they have for sales going on. I have never shopped at rays apple market but i know somoene that did when they were statioend here. She would go in and buy like 300 dollars worth of groceries but would only spend like 180 becuase she was an extream couponer. (she also does name brands only no off brands)
The commissary carries all name-brand things. They don't have a store-brand. That's why you can sometimes get things cheaper elsewhere. I've discovered that some stores have their store-brand items price similarly to the commissary prices, and when they go on sale, they are sometimes cheaper. That is for store-brand vs name-brand though, which sometimes can make a different in quality for some items.
I've never had a problem with customer service at the commissary, and I've never had a good customer service experience at wal-mart, to be honest.
And the commissary will accept manufacturers coupons, and they also hang up store coupons for items all the time that you can just rip one (or more) off while you're there. You can use a manufacturers coupon with those coupons and get even more savings. Just make sure the coupons have exp. dates. They won't accept them without one.
Just a price comparison... The commissary has had Maxwell House coffee for $6.99 for the big blue handled container, and they had $1.50 off coupons posted with it, making it only $5.49. Dillons was selling it for $13.00, and I saw a sale ad for it this weekend that only had it down to $10.
That's what i also like about commissary is there is no off brand and your right alot of the times you can get the name brand stuff at commy for the same price as walmart or hyvee brands depending on what you are getting.
Speaking of groceries idk if any of you have been to walmart (in JC) latley but del montie(sp) and green giant brand canned corn and green beens were on sale (was monday when i went) for 68 cents a can which are normally 1.18 i think the sign said.Im assuming its becuase thanksgiving is comming up and those are the 2 main vegies people use for thanksgiving dinner. I stocked up not for thanksgiving its becuase my husband goes though green beens like they are going out of style. Everytime i ask him what vegie he wants with dinner thats what he tells me. AT the moment he is at ALC so im atleast stocked up for when he comes back lol.
Honestly customer service doesn't matter to me if I'm going to be saving money! lol before we moved here I could feed me, my husband, my 3 year old and our dog (who eats A LOT!)for $200 a month. I just went to Dillion's yesterday and spent almost $80 on a weeks worth of food! And that's just for my 3 year old and me. (I bought dog food at Walmart earlier this month. And husband is still deployed.)
I've never had a problem with customer service at the commissary, and I've never had a good customer service experience at wal-mart, to be honest.
Honestly customer service doesn't matter to me if I'm going to be saving money!
I agree with both of these comments. The only people I could complain about at the commy, is the baggers, and its not really their fault. They are in a tough position... work for free, but assume tips. I'd rather they just be paid some flat rate and let them stop stressing. I'd also like the option to just bag my own crap, because nothing is worse than a sourpuss bagger. Be sour after I dont tip you, dont start your 'tude in the store... you dont know me.
The commissary does have off brands that are cheaper than name brand items; i.e. cereals, oatmeal, feminine hygiene products, etc. The only thing I thought I'd have to venture to the commissary for is Boar's Head meat and products; but, alas, Ray's Apple Market carries the brand! C:
I hadn't used coupons in at least fifteen years, until last month. We received some in the mail, clipped away to pass some time, and saved $45 at Ray's. Yeah, me!
So, the commissary charges a surcharge fee. Hmm. Well, Hy-Vee gives you a 5% military discount, as well as an additional 5% off if you use your own green bags vs their plastic or paper bags. Dillon's and Ray's each offer at least 5% in military discounts; Hy-Vee and Dillon's offer discounts and savings on their fuel; and, Ray's has a milk card that gets you free milk after every dozenth you buy.
Meat, meat, meat: Ray's all the way! So fresh. I buy quality over quantity; so, yeah...Ray's. It's clean, cozy, fresh, charming, friendly, and...baggers can't accept tips ;). I treat the store like my own little secret (I half don't want to share); but, you asked: I frequent the one on the corner of Seth Child and Anderson in Manhattan. The Hy-Vee I mentioned is off Tuttle Creek Blvd, next to the mall and Petco.
Dillon's on Anderson went to poo for me because I went to get a money order for my rent at the customer service desk last month (done via Western Union) and the lady working the counter was a total clue; she was rude and ran my debit card not once, but twice as credit. What did that do, you wonder? It made it so she withdrew money from my account that never went toward my rent; AND, she overrode my signature/pin code option when I told her she made the boo-boo. The higher up next to her said: oh well, too late, you'll have to wait for Western Union to refund you the funds! Up to 30-plus days: O-M-G! So not pleased. Thankfully, my Credit Union saw all the ways in which this boob messed up the transaction and permitted me to withdraw against the lost funds. Anywho, I hope this helps; and, to each their own. c:
Oh, I should mention, I frequent the Farmers' Market every Wednesday evening at CICO Park. That's where I get most of my fresh produce. That runs from 4-7 p.m.
I also shop at the East and West Side Markets; that can be a bit pricey for some, but I don't smoke or drink, wasting money on crap. Some people eat to live, I live to eat.
I'm wondering if it would be worth the gas to drive all the way into Manhattan?? I live really close to the commissary. I guess maybe if we did one big shopping trip and stocked up? (Which I can't do until I make room in my storage closet to put some kind of shelving unit!) I guess until than I'll just go to commissary with my husband
Well I can't go to the commissary (man I wish I had a military friend lol)!! I live in Manhattan & for the most part I go to Walmart because its convenient, but if you use coupons you can save alot if you go by what is on sale each week (you can find all the stores ads online, Dillons, Rays Applemarket, Hyvee, etc...) Dillons & Rays will double up to $1.00 so you can get some good savings...not sure its worth your drive here or not though guess it just depends what your running at the Commissary...good luck to you!
The commissary does have off brands that are cheaper than name brand item
They do have more than one brand for things and they have different prices, but they don't have STORE brands like the other stores. Wal-Mart has Great Value, Dillons has Kroger, etc.
If you lived on post, I wouldn't think it would save you much money to drive into Manhattan, let alone the time it takes as well. I grew up in Iowa, which is where Hy-Vee is headquartered out of, and the only reason we ever shopped at Hy-Vee was if they were the only ones that carried something we needed. They were almost always higher priced.
Every $100 you spend at Dillons gets you $0.10 off per gallon of gas, but only at KwikShop. And you also have to earn them all within a month, your total starts over at the beginning of the month. I shopped at Dillons when we were staying with family in Salina when we first moved here, and I compared some stuff to the commissary once we got our own place and the commissary was significantly cheaper.
I grew up in Iowa, which is where Hy-Vee is headquartered out of, and the only reason we ever shopped at Hy-Vee was if they were the only ones that carried something we needed. They were almost always higher priced.
I also grew up in Iowa my town in northern/ north central only has a hyvee and fairway so i would always shop at hyvee just becuase i dont like how fairway is set up. There are certaint things i like at hyvee that i can't get anywhere else but i won't go out of my way to get them. If im in manhattan i will stop by and pick them up. The few things would be Anderson Erickson Chip dip(BEST CHIP DIP EVER. I just got my friend hooked on it muahhahah) and also Anderson erickson egg nog at christmas time. I don't drink it but my husband does and thats the only egg nog he will drink. Oh and the last thing i would get is hyvee cottage cheese. But like i said im not going out of my way just to get those things at hyvee so i will do without before i make a speicial trip to manhattan for just that. If this hyvee carried more stuff that the hyvee back home did i would probably shop there more.
i would always shop at hyvee just becuase i dont like how fairway is set up.
LOL! We ALWAYS shopped at Fareway! I don't have any problem with Hy-Vee. I love that you can get awesome lunch there for fairly cheap and the big ones have lots to choose from. I just know that I've always had to spend more on groceries there. I don't have any personal vendetta against them, hah.
What town did you grow up in? (sorry to threadjack)