WOW! I agree, LET HIM WALK! It's not like he just skipped school. 2 measly days??? Go public school system, bravo to you for stickin' it to the man!! (hmm..not so much)
I hope to see this young man get a full-ride college scholarship in the very near future.
Why? Because he has a mother with cancer? This is what is wrong with society these days IMO. He's doing exactly what he should do for his parent. They bring you into this world and take care of you and in return you take care of them when they need it, period.
We don't know the entire situation. You guys are reading something online that people want you to read. I will not believe for one second that the school isn't letting him walk simply because he missed too much school because he was taking his mother to the doctors. When I was a senior in HS we were told it didn't matter what grades we had if we didn't pass our senior government final then we weren't graduating, no ifs ands or buts. No one believed it until a boy in our class failed and sure enough he didn't get his diploma but he was still allowed to walk in the ceremony and receive a "diploma", it was an empty envelope.
Dont get me wrong, it's awesome that he put his mother first, as he should, but if the only thing keeping him from having an excused tardy as opposed to an unexcused tardy was a doctor's note don't you think the minute he heard from the school that he would have went to his Mother's doctor and gotten a note?
All I'm saying is he did what he was supposed to do so why does that merrit a full scholarship? If universities handed out scholarships everytime someone did something nice or something they were supposed to do then everyone would go to school for free!
Maybe a doctor's note wouldn't count since it wasn't him going to the doctor and it was his mother going. When I saw comments about the doctors notes, that's what I was thinking too until I thought about it and realized when I was in school (at a few of my many many schools I attended) the doctors note had to be from the student's doctor.
I don't really think he should get a full ride scholarship though, there are far more students that deserve one and don't get them; for him to walk will be great though.
Having been a work-study to the dean of students at a university, I will tell you there are scholarships out there for everything under the sun. Why would I like to see him get a scholarship? Because some good well-to-do pillar of the community will see this young man's plight, relate to the hardships cancer puts on individuals' lives, and donate toward the betterment of our society. I watched the video and followed the news surrounding this story; he seems pretty deserving in my book.
And again, there are millions of people out there that are good pillar's of the community that might be more deserving. He has bad circumstances, we've all had our battles. I lost both of my parents when I was a baby but never expected anyone to hand me anything because I was in a bad fosterhome. It's life, life happens to everyone. Should he be allowed to walk, absolutely. If the black and white rules for his school district are that you cannot graduate if you have so many missed days then it is what it is. Yes, he absolutely should walk but maybe not get a diploma if he academically does not qualify to graduate due to his numerous missed school days. If the rules were bent for him because of his circumstances then that alone is devaluing all the other kids' diplomas. All the other kids that went to school when they were supposed to no matter what the circumstances.
If the rules were bent for him because of his circumstances then that alone is devaluing all the other kids' diplomas. All the other kids that went to school when they were supposed to no matter what the circumstances. WOW... Just because you had it hard doesn't mean you should devalue his hard work. Yes other kids have it hard but I know tons of people who would never take care of there parents. This young man had two jobs to support his mom! How the heck is that devaluing others diplomas?!?! If you go to the website all the kids from his class support him.
Who said anything about his character or him having jobs? You're right there are a million people that wouldn't do what he did. The black and white matter is there are rules and guidelines and they are there for a reason. I'm not trashing the kid, I'm not saying he shouldn't graduate but I am saying that what is good for the goose is good for the gander.
Cancer robbed this kid of his youth; over the course of six years, he took on two jobs to aid and care of his ailing mother.
You should note that I did not post that he aught to walk; merely that I'd like to see a college scholarship come his way. In the course of a nomination process, I would gladly like to see an essay pleading his case.
war robbed alot of kids of their parents and youth...it's life! Death is a part of life you can't go thru life getting hand outs and having rules bent for you because you had to deal with life...that is what's wrong with people these days.
God forbid my children lost their parent(s), they'd have life insurance and college covered. I'm sorry you have such a bleak outlook on life, but it really doesn't relate to this kid's misfortune.
war robbed alot of kids of their parents and youth...it's life! Death is a part of life you can't go thru life getting hand outs and having rules bent for you because you had to deal with life...that is what's wrong with people these days. Who pi$$ed in your cornflakes? Do you not have any sympathy?
BTW he's walking his mom gets to see him graduate :) But he's not allowed to go to prom which he doesn't care about he just wanted him mom to see him graduate.
Did you not see ANYTHING that I wrote or did you just see what you wanted to argue with? I SAID I felt that he deffinately should be allowed to walk with his class and be a part of the ceremony but maybe not receive his diploma if he did not have the qualifications for it.
He was going to get his diploma. I read what you wrote you just have no sympathy at all. Just because you had it hard doesn't mean you have to have a stick in your butt with other people you can show sympathy to others. Its ok
And when did I say I didn't have sympathy? EVERYONE in life has issues, some more then others. When will someone stand up and say the rules are the rules and they are in place for a reason and even though I can have EMPATHY for a person doesn't mean the situation is changed.
Don't even get me seriously started on this whole subject. In no way am I saying because I wasn't given a handout then no one else should because I never expected it. I learned that LIFE HAPPENS and you deal with it. This is a teenage boy that was supposed to be in school, period. As a parent it is your responsability to make sure your children are doing what they are supposed to do when they are supposed to do it, I.E. going to school when they are supposed to. If this kid didnt go to school because his Mom was a drunk and he had to get a job to keep a roof over his sibling's heads would this have become a national issue? Probably not.
Does anyone sit back and think for one second about the message that is being given to this kid along with his class mates? You can't go thru life not following rules because of circumstances weather they are good bad or indifferent. Sometimes life sucks and sometimes things don't work out the way you wanted or expected them to but that is life, there is and always will be consiquences for your actions. In no way do I not have empathy for this family but if the school bends the rules "just this one time" for this situation what will come up next year and the year after that?
There are always exceptions to the rules. My friends brother died from cancer and she didn't have to take her finals because they made an exception to the rules because it was more important for her to be with her family. In life there are always exceptions. Even if there's people who have a stick in there butt and don't think there should be. If it came down to someone taking care of there loved one over school. The loved one should come first. School you can make up. You never know how much time you have with someone till there gone.
I'm with you DLD. There's an exception to every rule ever made where a bad situation is created, but you have to draw lines, somewhere.
If the only reason this kid wasn't going to get to walk at graduation was because he missed days caring for his mom, then I agree that he should be able to walk. The way I understood it, he also missed because of the jobs he took on. That's a crappy situation, but still not an excused absence for school. You would have all kinds of kids not showing up at school and saying they were "working".
I don't think he should get a scholarship, unless there is some private entity out there who decides to give him one.
DLD isn't being a B****. She's being real. There are people all over who are overcoming bad situations. Only some of them are lucky enough to get their story picked up by the media and petitions drafted pleading their case. I think these days people feel like they are 'making a difference' by signing petitions for stories they hear about on the news and sitting at home being "sympathetic." I'm sure this kid appreciates the empathy,but he would've much rather had someone help take his mom to the Dr. or pay for her care so he didn't spend so much time out of school and get put in this situation to begin with. Being a real-life good Samaritan goes a lot further than signing petitions online.
In this case, I'm glad the school made the exception so the kid's mom could enjoy his graduation, and I hope he's able to attend college and become a successful member of society.