Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Bottle Vs. Breast

who's talking here?

~*BrinA*~ 1
Angie33 1
Proud Cav. Wife 4
Candice 1
Cristy 1
FortRileyMom3 2
MichelleMae 1
Diana 2
lacie 1
My 3 girls 1
*SoCal Princess* 1
IOWA GIRL 1
Yard 1
daisypetals2000 2
FreeLittleFootFanClub 1
Deon 1
ArmyWifey5585 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Proud Cav. Wife --- 17 years ago -

I am about 23 weeks pregnant now, and it seems like everyone wants to know "Are you going to breast feed". Well I thought I was, but then I hear all these horror stories about the pain, leaking and inconvenience. I have already researched the formula vs. breast milk debate online. I guess what I am looking for here is were you able too, How long, and is it really as miserable as I seem to be getting told it is. I just feel nervous and am getting the 1st time Mommy nerves I think. I just want some opinions and after all I know you ladies are great at that! 

*SoCal Princess* --- 17 years ago -

i personally never did. my oldest was in icu, and by the time i could see her, she was already bottlefed so she wouldnt take. my second, i was not producing enough. i tried to pump that hurt like no other. my friend breast fed all three of hers and she said she wouldnt change it. i dont think that if u breast feed a baby it will be any smarter or whatever than a bottle fed child. both of mine r smart. if you are worried about the pain then pump. its all inconvient. you will have to get up anyway. just the boob is there and you can just pull it out instead of making a bottle, heating it up, and all that. theres pros and cons to it all. good luck. 

Proud Cav. Wife --- 17 years ago -

Thank you, I appreciate the response! 

FortRileyMom3 --- 17 years ago -

I have three kids and didnt produce enough to breast feed. So I bottle fed all of them. They were healthy children with very few colds,fevers or anything. The one thing I can remember is my oldest had a high fever once but that is because she was cutting her molars. So that had nothing to do with being bottle fed vs. breast fed. All of mine are straight A kids also. I think it is your choice noone elses. You will find some people are very adamant about breast feeding. But I say it is what you want...you're the parent. 

Cristy --- 17 years ago -

The decision is truly yours but I was able to breastfeed my son for his first year and the only pain I experienced was when his first tooth came in and he bit me (It didn't hurt as much as it shocked me) but I plugged his nose and made him let go and he never did it again. He even had all of his baby teeth before his first birthday and I never had any problems. A lot of people experience pain because they can't get the baby to latch on right and I had a problem with my son at first but Mercy has a lactation consultant and after seeing her one time we got the latch right and everything was great. For me Breast feeding was easier and less of a hassle because I never had to worry about having enough money for formula, or forgetting to buy it at the store and running out in the middle of the night, having to get out of bed to make bottles (My son slept in a bassinet next to our bed for the first few months so I just reached over and got him when he got hungry and put him back and never had to get out of bed), there was no worrying about taking liquids etc. on the plane, no hassle during car trips, plus the extra money not spent on formula we got to spend elsewhere (Like on my Medela Breast Pump which I LOVE). I mean it really is your decision but if you decide to try it make sure you see a lactation consultant if you are having problems (they are a HUGE help) and check out the breast feeding class that they offer at Mercy (I did and it taught me several things about breast feeding I didn't find while researching it). I am 20 weeks with my 2nd and plan to do it all over again if all goes well :) Good Luck! 

Angie33 --- 17 years ago -

I bottle fed my first and breast fed my second and I have to say that breast feeding is definitely better for the baby. My oldest was sick ALL the time and seemed to catch any and everything that was going around while my youngest had only one ear infection. The benefits of breastfeeding are enormous. I just wished that I had knew more about it when my oldest was a baby and I would have breastfed her also. I will say this, it is painful and I also had a clogged milk duct and that was painful more than you know but I got thru it and ended up breastfeeding her until she was 6 months old and I am so glad that I could do that for my baby. Best of luck in your decision! 

FortRileyMom3 --- 17 years ago -

my oldest had 2 ear infections, my second had about 2 and my youngest had no ear infections all bottle fed. I believe it is a personal choice, you can find pro's and cons on both sides, depending on which side you are leaning on is what you find the most pros on. 

Yard --- 17 years ago -

It is definitely your personal choice, but I do believe that breast feeding definitely makes them healthier when it comes to sickness. I breastfed my oldest for 9 months when she decided to wein herself, she is 4 now and to this day has never had any ear infection or really any sickness at all. A cough here and there but nothing to go to the doctor for. My second child I just recently stopped nursing her at 18 months. I definitely agree that bottle feeding is definitely more convenient, but in the long run I think it pays to nurse. It makes a special bond between you and the baby that only you and the baby can experience and it is definitely healthier. Nursing is what GOD intended us to do which I know there are circumstances in which people cannot do it. My best friend wanted to nurse her son sooo bad but didnt produce enough and some babies just dont latch on properly or whatever. But in my opinion it is definitely worth trying and it wont necessarily be easy but it gets better with time. My first one I cracked and bled with bc I didnt know it at the time but she wasnt latching on properly but after 2 months we got the hang of it and it just come so natural for the both of us. My second latched on properly from hour 1 and never had any problems. Just try it, dont let no one scare you bc everyone has different experiences. Everyone should give it a try and if it dont work go to the bottle in my opinion!!! 

~*BrinA*~ --- 17 years ago -

I did both breast and bottle. But I had the total oppisate problem, I could have breast fed 12 babies with the amount of milk i produced. LOL With my first baby I tried my hardest to breastfeed her and my nipples got cracked and where bleeding and it was a horrible pain, leaking everywhere and when she was on one side it would just poor out of the other lol So i would pump on one side while feeding on the other. I will say this though, It helps TREMENDESLY for losing babyweight. It will contract your uteris and make your stomache smaller! I would feel my stomache cramping down there every time i fed them wich honestly is a big PLUS! I was only able to feed them both for about 6 weeks each, because it would get really painful. If I where you I would just try it and see how it goes! There is this stuff in a purple tube called Lasinoh (i think thats how you spell it) and its lanolin stuff that keeps your nips supple and soft, and its safe to put on there as much as you need it and it will stop chafing and bleeding! (safe to use when baby is latched on also) THIS STUFF SAVED MY PAIN lol With my second my boobs got infected and went septic, and I had to be hospitalized for a night, but they put me on antibiotics, told me to pump once and discard all of the milk and then I could start breast feeding again. Personally Its a very good thing for me because it helped me lose some of the baby weight. You do burn alot of calories when breast feeding, its good for you and your baby. And Neither of my kids got feevers or sick at ALL until they where about 2 years old. Of course there where feevers when they where cutting teeth but thats just normal. So thats my story and whatever you decide to do is up to you, Remember this.. its been done since humans where put on this earth.. its the most natural thing you can do for you and your child and it will also help you bond with your baby :) I really think its a great thing to do, but in the end it is all up to you :) 

Proud Cav. Wife --- 17 years ago -

Thanks everyone! I do have a super nice pump, and the bottles that are supposed to make doing both easier. My husband wants us to give it a month at least. Or until the end of winter because of colds and flus. 

FreeLittleFootFanClub --- 17 years ago -

I had all sorts of problems with breast feeding. With my last one though she was a NICU baby. I pumped every day and brought it up to her. I got a nipple shield to make her latching on easier. I didnt do it for too long (2 months) but I still feel it helped her. Once again I dont think she ever really has been sick. Your decision all the way and even if You try it and dont like it you can always stop. Or you can pump for a while if you decide your baby cant latch properly etc... 

IOWA GIRL --- 17 years ago -

I dont think breast feeding prevents the kid from being sick my friend has 4 kids she brest fed them all and they still get sick atleast once every 3-6 months. The oldest is 5 and the youngest is 3 months. rather it be a cold, ear infection, runs whatever they still seem to get sick every 3-6 months and they were healthy babies when they were born. So i dont belive brest feeding is going to make a baby healthier even tho they say it does 

Diana --- 17 years ago -

My eldest was in ICU and I had a very difficult time breastfeeding. So I took the hard route. I pumped my breasts every 2 hours and bottlefed him my breastmilk. It's a lot of work but ultimately it's about what's healthier for your child. I've actually never had any success (even with a lactation consultant)but they have had breastmilk. My eldest .. even though he was in ICU (born prematurely) was amazingly discharged a week after, when doctors had thought he would be in there for at least 6 weeks. He is now in the 99th percentile for height and doing well on weight. My recommendation is this .. for your child any discomfort is worth it. But before you get yourself worked up. Try it. When they actually do latch on, the moment is beautiful. The bonding is beautiful. If the nurse asks you and you're still not sure, just say both. Most medical professions do push the mother the breastfeed since the child is able to build a stronger immune system through the mother and the mother's milk is supposed to be perfect food. =) Good luck 

Diana --- 17 years ago -

Ahh one more thing .. they say that bottle fed babies tend to be more overweight in the future than breastfed babies. Not sure if there's any truth to that. But my kids are skinnier than most of the babies I've seen that are bottlefed. Talk to your doctor. 

Candice --- 17 years ago -

I breastfed my son for 7 weeks until I ran out of milk. I have to admit that he has had his problems with colds and flus, but the Doc said it is because he had problems when he was born. My son was born without a kidney and his immune system is low. I have to fed him plenty of vitamins and things to keep him healthy! He loves them, thank goodness! He is now a healthy happy 2yo! There was pain and discomfort during breastfeeding, however, I agree with what was said above, discomfort is worth it when it comes to your child. It is amazing feeling to be able to bond like that with your newborn! The lanolin stuff mentioned above WORKED WONDERS on the sore spots on my nipples. If you plan to breastfeed, I would buy some. Near the diaper rash ointment in the baby dept. Good Luck, whatever you choose! 

lacie --- 17 years ago -

I personally have done both. I thought with my first one it was gross and I wasnt even going to try. I was 21 and my mom said it was the best and I wasn't even going to try. She was strictly a bottle baby with formula and she is healthy and super smart. Now my son my husband really wanted me to try it and I said I would give it a shot. I ended up nursing him until his 1st bday. He has been extremely healthy and we havent had too many trips to the dr at all. Besides normal routine ones. It is a little uncomfortable until you get used to it and the worst pain I had was when my milk first came in and we were both still learning. It really comes down to fining a comfortable feeding position for you and then your good I think. I was a milk cow and since my husband wasn't around my son wouldnt take a bottle at all. But I had to pump about 8 times a day on top of my son eating. But it does help you lose the weight a little faster and I think you bond so much more if you breastfeed IMO. it is a little more time constraining if you are a lot more active and go out to lots of places, but if you get your son or daughter used to taking a bottle then it shouldnt be as bad. But I can tell you IMO your baby wont take a bottle from you I would have your husband do it. As they smell the milk on you and they know whats there. But I would recommend it, but I am not a Dr either. But all I can say is try I wish I would have done it with my first now that I know what the experience was like. Wish you the best of luck. 

Deon --- 17 years ago -

Breast feeding is wonderful. I have 4 sons and they were all breastfeed. Try it it's wonderful to be able to bond with your baby that way... 

MichelleMae --- 17 years ago -

I don't necessarily believe the whole "Breastfeeding makes babies healthies." and " Bottle fed babies tend to be overweight." I was the only one breastfed of my siblings and I am a medical nightmare and the most overweight of the 3 of us-although I was never overweight as a child. However I'm not saying this is always the case. If I ever have children I will definitely try breastfeeding first and if it doesn't work it doesn't work. Best of luck. :) 

daisypetals2000 --- 17 years ago -

totally agree that it is your personal choice to decide what works for you and your family. B/f does take ALOT of dedication and patience as breastfed babies eat more freqently and are little poop machines. lol. The doctor says it is because breastmilk is pre-digested (when compared to formula). I have never been a big milk producer and thus my babies were bottle fed from early on, but I am not against it. They are all 4 very healthy and extremely intelligent. The best advice i can give is that if you chose the breast feeding route, drink TONS of water and don't go cheap on a pump... i did that with my second child and it was not effective AT ALL. I bought a Medela Pump-in-Style Advance and it was a fantastic pump. It has adjustments for mothers comfort. It is about a $300 pump, but I sware it was worth it compared to the $50 one. I am sure some of the other mommies can give you some suggestions for pumps that worked for them. I have also heard that WIC will give you a pump too. Idk how true that is. Anyway, in short, if you decide to bottle feed, don't let anyone make you feel "guilty" for doing it - there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with it. The most important thing is that you love and nurture your baby - regardless of how it is fed. :) best wishes... amy 

daisypetals2000 --- 17 years ago -

totally agree that it is your personal choice to decide what works for you and your family. B/f does take ALOT of dedication and patience as breastfed babies eat more freqently and are little poop machines. lol. The doctor says it is because breastmilk is pre-digested (when compared to formula). I have never been a big milk producer and thus my babies were bottle fed from early on, but I am not against it. They are all 4 very healthy and extremely intelligent. The best advice i can give is that if you chose the breast feeding route, drink TONS of water and don't go cheap on a pump... i did that with my second child and it was not effective AT ALL. I bought a Medela Pump-in-Style Advance and it was a fantastic pump. It has adjustments for mothers comfort. It is about a $300 pump, but I sware it was worth it compared to the $50 one. I am sure some of the other mommies can give you some suggestions for pumps that worked for them. I have also heard that WIC will give you a pump too. Idk how true that is. Anyway, in short, if you decide to bottle feed, don't let anyone make you feel "guilty" for doing it - there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with it. The most important thing is that you love and nurture your baby - regardless of how it is fed. :) best wishes... amy 

My 3 girls --- 17 years ago -

I breast fed all 3 of mine. And it for the most part was a great experience and i if asked opinion always recommend. The bonding is wonderful the convenience especially in the middle of the night is awesome don't need to go get formula and bottle and make it's already right there. If latch on wrong hurts but just be sure to take right off within a few days they usually get it if not right away. If you are going to Manhattan the lactation specialist there is great and will help you through any problems even after you leave she is just a phone call away. When milk first comes in some discomfort but after that usually smooth sailing and the greatest experience. The expense of formula also makes it a great experience if think of all the money saving and the convenience of not having to go get it. Good luck with your choice and if chose remember after first two weeks it's a breeze make it to that mark and your good. So just go into that may be hard at first once you both have it figured out usually smooth sailing. 

Proud Cav. Wife --- 17 years ago -

Is there any harm in pumping only. I think I would be most comfortable if I could pump and place in a bottle. I feel like that would make me the most comfortable, I want to try and make it to a year, if I can. We will see. 

ArmyWifey5585 --- 17 years ago -

I didnt breastfeed and my daughter is awesome.All that stuff they say like breastmilk makes babies smarter and less prone to being sick is all hype. My baby was sitting on her own at 3 months old, crawling at 5 months old, never got sick EVER and now is 7 months old and starting walking. Breastmilk isnt all its cracked up to be, formula is just as good for your baby and more convienent. And now formula has immune boosters in it to support baby immune systems. In my opinion.. its all the same and up to the mother! 

ArmyWifey5585 --- 17 years ago -

I agree with Amy. I didnt breastfeed and my daughter is awesome. All that stuff they say like breastmilk makes babies smarter and less prone to being sick isnt all true. My baby was sitting on her own at 3 months old, crawling at 5 months old, never got sick EVER and now is 7 months old and starting walking. Breastmilk isnt all its cracked up to be, formula is just as good for your baby and more convienent. And now formula has immune boosters in it to support baby immune systems. And as far as bonding, whether you give your baby a bottle or your breat you are still bonding. In my opinion.. its all the same and up to the mother! 

ArmyWifey5585 --- 17 years ago -

LOL sorry that got posted twice 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground