I would like anyone's opinion on this subject... as well as any rules regarding pets on post... we are considering moving on post but even after weighing the pros & cons just can't decide especially after reading all of the post on here about the housing situation.
Honestly, we chose to live off post.
We thought about it and you get 959 for BAH and you can come out ahead. where as if you move on post you get that taken away plus you pay for internet and cable. and we found an apartment complex with cable and water included in our rent! just my opinion!!
I think it really depends on your situation. I personally would like to live off post as long as I can. On post, you've got more rules and regulations, not much of a variety (what cable company you want, etc), and not too much of a choice of where you want to live. I like the fact that off post, you get to choose where you live, and all of the BAH is not gone at the end of the month! JMO
@stacey My hubby was in army when we married. I refused to ever live on post. I am not the one in the army. I refuse to be told that if I want a pool for my kids after labor day I can. Or any of the other stupid rules.
Like Bree said we come out ahead living off post. We are buying our house and BAH covers mortgage, utilites, and cell phone (no home phone). We are essentially saving our BAH.
We have a budget and try not to go over my hubby's BAH... between all of our utilities, cell, and rent (we are only here til 05/2011, so we decided not to buy here) we sorta even out except for the fuel cost of driving to & from post each day & having to fill the propane tank (which is something we have never had before so we were new to that, it was almost $300 to fill) so with those added expenses we are actually going over his BAH (it went down when we pcs'd here, they said the cost of living was less which is sooooo untrue) couldn't find anything decent and affordable in JC or Manhattan which would allow pets is the reason we have moved out to the country
@ Stacey, I think you should just go ahead and put your name on the housing waiting list. If you wait the list will only get longer. You are not obligated to live on post if you don't like where they put you.
This is the first time we're actually staying on post after all these years of being in the military and I like it better than I thought I would. It just all depends on what you want. I like staying on post because for us it's much more convenient. The kids school are close by and the hubby can come home for lunch everyday without having to deal with the gate traffic and he doesn't eat out for lunch anymore so that saves some money too. Anyway, while you're deciding on what to do, I think it won't hurt to put your name on the list and maybe when it's your turn you'll know what you want to do by then. Good luck!
Yep, he's been pretty lucky so far. Except for the past week and a half they've been doing 12 hour shifts on and off so no lunch for him cause he's sleeping at lunch time...lol
we are actually going over his BAH
We were going over the bah when we lived off post but at the time bah for an e4 was only 836 and now its 9 something but we were paying 700 alone for rent the other 150 or whatever it was was not covering the utilties, gas and water. we were going over just in those 3 alone. Which forced us to move to post becuase we were barly serviving. Now we are getting over 1000 for bah becuase he just got promoted a month ago (even tho it all goes to housing)i would concider moving off post but he gets deployed in the spring and when he gets back in 2011 he wants to put his orders in to go somewhere else. so no since in moving back off post If you are going to move in 2011I would just put up with it for another 1 1/2 years becuase you will probably wait at least 6 months for housnig. so by the time you get moved in and get settled you will be moving agian. JMO
We bought a home off post and after about a year and a half we ended up selling it because we were paying out of pocket so much more money. We live about 45 minutes from post and at the time that is when gas was almost $4.00/gal so we decided to move on post and have been able to regain our finances again. Moving on post is about how well you can handle it, my husband and I enjoy it because he does get to come home from PT and for lunch and right after work, I work across the street almost from our house, but we don't have animals, we are quiet people, so for us it works, just giving my experience with on post living.
We bought a home off post and after about a year and a half we ended up selling it because we were paying out of pocket so much more money. We live about 45 minutes from post and at the time that is when gas was almost $4.00/gal so we decided to move on post and have been able to regain our finances again. Moving on post is about how well you can handle it, my husband and I enjoy it because he does get to come home from PT and for lunch and right after work, I work across the street almost from our house, but we don't have animals, we are quiet people, so for us it works, just giving my experience with on post living.
although I live on post, if I had to do it over again and we were not preparing to retire in 2 yrs, there would be no way in hell I would live on post ever again.
You are not obligated to live on post if you don't like where they put you.
Be aware that when you accept housing on post, you are entering into a one year lease, unless you get orders!
Personally, I hate living on post. But, it's mainly because I feel like I don't have any privacy. I like living in the country, and if I had it my way, that's where I would be right now! It just depends on what you are looking for in a house.
when we were living off post we couldnt find a decent 4 bedroom house for under $1000 a month and with bah only being 9something we were drowning...since we got moved to post we have saved so much money that we actually have extra spending money to take our girls and do fun things with them. it took us about 4 months of being on the waiting list for a 4 bedroom before we got out house. i definitely think that on post is so much better financially than on post.
Lived off post for the first 6 months we were here. Housing costs (including utilities) put us over our BAH by over 200/month. This was for a 3 bedroom townhome at E-5 BAH. While we would be breaking even now, we gained about 400 sq feet of living space and an extra bedroom. I think it really depends on where you live off post vs what they offer you on post. I know there were some areas on post that we would not have accepted. Just as there were many area of JC that I would not have lived in.
I do like having other military wives nearby. It helps while hubby is deployed. I guess the pool regulations don't bug me too much as I don't want to put one up. I have a fence up now, more to keep the kids out than anything.
The other issues I have are the same anywhere you rent (until I can move into and all adult community - ha ha) including a few "bad" neighbors and unwatched kids.
i live on post and love it. lived off post for about 9 months and hated it. But I guess it depends on what housing area you get. I live in a very peaceful neighborhood and such quiet neighbors, I never see them. What can I say, it's perfect...lol!
lol, thanks again guys 4 all the reply's... my main concerns really are the pet issues (if anyone knows the rules & regs 4 sure plz let me know) we have 3 dogs and I was told that u have 2 pay 2 have a fence put up by a company with certain specs (we can't afford that, my hubby put the fence up here himself) and the fact that we have a 15 yr old girl (my lil sis whom we have custody of) and who lives with us but my hubby has 2 boys that spend 4 months a year with us but we don't have primary custody so does anyone know if we would get just a 2 bdrm??? b/c that would leave us with nowhere for the boys to even sleep when they are with us (guess i shoulda explained all of this earlier, lol) hubby got home tonight and we talked a bit, figured up that between his fuel (he has a jacked up 4x4 that sucks gas) and his lunches we spend an extra $400 a month living off post
It depens on what fence company you go with depends on what you are going to get charged. It also depends on how big you want your fence. You can also if you want since you baught your fence take it down and bring it to post with you and put it up yourself. You have to get approved by housing to put up your own fence tho. BUt they will let you put up your own fence. Or atleast thats what i was told. There for you wouldnt have that montly payment for the fence payment. EVen if you left your fence and did a montly payment for a fence you still would come out ahead because you are already going over your bah for the cost of lving and it sounds like you are going quit a bit over so an extra 25-50 dollars a month wont be anything compaired to what you are spending now. yes you are only allowed 3 pets total doesnt matter if you have 1 indoor 2 out door or whatever its 2 total. ANd yes there are certain breeds that you are not allowed to have on post. Pitbulls, huskies(i think) and some other im not sure of all if you go to rileys website i think there is a list of what is not allowed on post.
the bedroom situatuion would be something that you would have to talk to relocation about....there is a possibility that they would give you a 3 bedroom so there was an extra room for the boys to sleep in if there are court papers proving you have them for that extended period of time. as far as the fence goes you can put up your own fence if you would like to. of course it has to be within your property line of the house you live in and you are responsible for filling in the holes if you move to a different house on post or pcs out. we go thru oneaccord fence company and pay $28 a month for 90 ft of chainlink fence and when we move they take the fence down and fill the holes and will move the fence for us if we get moved to different housing on post for whatever reason. hope this helps
I hated living on post! We have a german shepherd that will jump a four foot fence in a heart beat. They won't let you put up a higher fence, then said you can no longer tie up the dog inside the fence if he jumps it. They only allow three pets on post, if the mps catch your pets running loose, whoever is in the army can get in trouble. We come out ahead living off post as well.
I live on post because I have 2 danes, its not easy trying to find a place off post if you have big dogs, or animals for that matter, not to mention the pet deposits you haveto pay off post. I have had some issues getting a fence but thats because I needed a 6ft fence, but I finally got it. I have no issues with Picerne, everytime something breaks they are usually out here with in a day or so to fix it depending on what it is. If its something important it takes maybe 30 minutes. Ilive in the remodled ones and they are nice. Lots of room!
then said you can no longer tie up the dog inside the
Housing says you cant tie your dogs up outside in a fenced in yard. Ask animal control and they will tell you that you can as long as the dog is in the center of the yard and cannot reach the fence. They told me this a month or 2 ago the last time my dogs got out. When she told me this i said i have heard that from a mp befor i thought it was against post regulatiosn she siad not if you have a fenced in yard. Now if you dont have a fenced in yard then it is agianst post regulations becuase any kids passing by can come let your dog loose. So ever since then i have put my boxer on the chain becuase i was told i could and i have yet to hear housing say anything to me about it.
Picerne housing regulations state you CANNOT tie your dogs out with or without a fence. Honestly it doesn't matter what animal control says bece in the end they are not the ones writting you up for violations, it will be housing. But they should be working together to get the same message out.
Yes i know housing says you CAN NOT tie your dog up rather its fenced in or not. BUt ever sicne Animal control/mps have told me i could i have yet to hear housing say anything and im going to contiue to tie up my boxer that likes to jump the fence untill housing does say something to me. Then when they do say something to me im gonna tell them well i was told i could by the animal control and mps so someone needs to get on the same page
well after talking to everyone and setting us up a budget we have decided to definately move on post (still on the wait list though, they said 2 mo's) I have had several interviews and plan on going to the job fair this week but no job yet so we're living on just his salary since arriving here... had the propane man out last week who filled up the tank for $280 and said that in this old of a house (it has been remodled but still no insulation in the attic and not the best energy eff windows) that we should go thru a tank about every month and 1/2... OMG thats an extra $150 a month added to everything else, at this point groceries will be hard to come by lol so on post housing here we come!!! Thanks for all the opinions & advise!!!