Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

You be the judge ......

who's talking here?

~*BrinA*~ 1
BadLuckMommy 1
Natalie 2
daisypetals2000 2
Blondie 1
kris 11
~*Kandice*~ 2
*~Kristle~* 2
Deon's wife (Donna) 1
Allie1997 1
indymom 1
LilMrsNelson 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

kris --- 16 years ago -

I am not looking for a slighted view , but am curious how others not in this situation see it... please be honest .

Your child is at school and sees an offensive drawing on an outer building wall ( think porno style ) This child makes a choice to cover said pic with a smile face , ( in washable marker) in the process they are seen by an officer who then cites them for destruction of public property, and issues them their rights. This child is instructed to appear for court, to plea on the above charge. Now here is your chance to say what you think, but let me warn you , this story is not what it appears. When 5 people have commented , more will be revealed. I am curious to the reactions this topic will bring for a reason, so again all I ask is please be honest with your thoughts. Thanks. 

Natalie --- 16 years ago -

I think that the schools expect our kids to be mature - make mature decisions but when a student makes what the school says is the wrong decision (cover the offensive drawing) then they are punished. Yeah, maybe he should have ran to the office and reported it, but then again, maybe that was his intentions after he took care of it in the best way he could think of at that moment! Personally I think the school should be glad that someone was actually thinking enough to get rid of the porn that was on the wall in the first place instead of running to get everyone to look at it! 

Deon's wife (Donna) --- 16 years ago -

I feel he was wrong. He should have told someone that could have contacted the city so they could takecare of it. 2 wrongs don't make a right! JMO 

~*BrinA*~ --- 16 years ago -

Hmm how long has the picture been on the wall? If the kid was trying to cover it up I could see why he got caught and got in trouble.. basically he got caught coloring on the wall, therefore he is in trouble because he was the one they saw.

on the other hand...I have heard so many stories about the schools out here over reacting when a kid does something wrong.

They have to know that kids will be kids and not all of them think past what they are doing wheather for a right reason or a wrong reason. Also, the fact that he was trying to cover it up should mean something and I hope he doesn't get in too much trouble for it. Sometimes the people who are punished are the ones trying to do something good, and that just isn't right.

The fact that he has to go to court over something like this would probably piss me off to the point of no return and I would be going to jail myself, because thats bullsh@t. Why didn't the school do something to remove the offencive material in the first place???? 

Allie1997 --- 16 years ago -

I think that child should have went to an adult and reported the offensive image.
If it were my child, I'd be proud that they would want to "cover" the image but mad that they would vandalize property. 

kris --- 16 years ago -

Wow , lots of different opinions, this is good to see. I want to say by the way , I am not stirring drama for all those who like to lurk, I truely just want to see first reactions with the basic info, that is why I will give it til 5 comments have been made. I want to see how others see things in different situations. 

*~Kristle~* --- 16 years ago -

I think the second child should have gone to someone and let them know it was there, they had a good idea covering it up so that the child and others did not have to look at it, but IMO it was still wrong to draw on the property no matter the circumstance. 

indymom --- 16 years ago -

I think if the child is old enough to know that any vandalism is wrong he should be punished, but accordingly. Maybe some community service. If he was too young to recognize what he was doing was wrong then just having him help clean it up. Kids don't always think things through, at any age. 

kris --- 16 years ago -

Ok , here is more for you . The child that committed this offense is in High School , is autistic, and didn't lie about what they did. The crime is max 180 days in Jail with a $1000 fine for the offense and additional $285 for court costs and $1000 retainer for a lawyer. The minimal for said charge is 7 days in jail, and half of the fine and all of the other fees at full cost. 

kris --- 16 years ago -

BTW they did offer to clean off the smiley face. And they were going to tell an adult since no onther students were willing to go. I agree that they should have some form of repercussion, but fell that the above options were to steep , when considering that this child did not understand their rights when , did not destroy any beuilding ( because after this the wall was washed and again revealed what was beneath) , and no other child was questioned and no parents were notified. 

~*Kandice*~ --- 16 years ago -

I was arrested for vandalizing a car(I wrote on the windows with car window chalk but some guy wrote f you on the window and thats what got us in trouble) All I had to pay was 50 dollars for the guy to detail his car.

I think that the kids should have told someone that the offensive drawing was there instead of trying to cover it up. I think they really just need a slap on the hand and nothing harsh. I would probably make them cover it up since thats what they were trying to do in the first place. Jail time is harsh to me. Heck the fines are way to high too. 

kris --- 16 years ago -

I agreed the fines are to high , but according to a local lawyer the city is trying to increase revenues (sp?)

I am the mom of said child , and while I think he should have some form of concequenes, I couldn't believe that no one realized that during all of the reporting no one contacted a teacher, parent or case manager that knew my son. I have no problem with him getting community service, paying reasonable fines, etc. But I do have an issue with the fact that until I went to court with him , no one and I mean no one helped him to understand that he was being charged as an adult. He does not reason like an adult , the judge actually found him to be indegent and appointed an attorney for him. When I spoke with the school , they couldn't beleive how this was handled either. My son has never been in trouble with anyone, including the school, carries and A-B average in school , volunteers , and is involved in several school activities. He was suspended for 3 days , sent to the Dixon center and did not receive his work to do while there til the last day he was there. Now personally I went to pick up his work so that he wouldn't fall behind and was told it would be sent accordingly, since it wasn't he didn't get enough time to complete the work and didn't recieve full credit for it. And as a result now he gets nervous when he sees any officers in school because he thinks they are watching him now for another reason to send him away. Talk about lasting impressions. 

~*Kandice*~ --- 16 years ago -

I cant believe how harsh they are being. I had never got in trouble either and thats why my fines were low and its not on my record. I would do what I could to fight it. I think the most harsh thing he should get is to just pain the wall and cover up the stuff. Thats really all I see that they could even do. Sorry you and your son are having to go through this! 

kris --- 16 years ago -

Kandice Ty. As for the porn it was removed the next day with chemicals. So having him paint the wall is not an option, I have tried to help him to understand that he should have went straight to an adult , but as I stated he does not reason like you or I, so in his mind , what he did was not a crime , what was done prior was, and he doesn't understand why no one who saw it did anything . He told the judge his reasons for coving it and even the judge could help but become upset at the situation. Hense the appointed attorney. And we are fighting it, because although what he did was not really the smartest choice , it was a choice made in thought of others being exposed to the original drawing. Had anyone one else said anything or even stated that it was there prior to him coming out , then maybe things would have been dealt with differently. But not one student came forward, until after he was charged. 

LilMrsNelson --- 16 years ago -

You do the crime you do the time.... I think that once he goes to court and they hear his story and circumstance and this being a first offense then they should drop some of the fines and give him community service. Good luck in court. 

LilMrsNelson --- 16 years ago -

sorry didnt read that you already went to court, i think the fines are way too high!!! 

BadLuckMommy --- 16 years ago -

Honestly, because he was covering a porn type painting he shouldn't be punished except for maybe some community service or something, if anything he was helping the community out by trying to cover up someone else's wrong doings. They seen what was under the smiley face, I am not sure about it. I know two wrongs don't make a right but all the fines and everything else included is BS! If the judge was even upset by this, I would deff ask for a re trail, and try to get his sentence reduced! Sorry to hear about it Kris, I hope Seth is doing ok, tell him he was not wrong 

daisypetals2000 --- 16 years ago -

okay... my opinion is swayed by my own understanding of autism. all b/s aside...

while I understand that what was done was wrong - most typical 18 year olds are capabale of clearly understanding that graffiti is a criminal offence; be it covering up something or drawing the regular pic. However, we are not talking about a typical 18 year old (sorry S if you are reading this... I mean this with the best of heart) we are talking about someone who thinks outside the typical box in extraordinary ways. In his mind, he was correcting a wrong - not creating one. I personally am saddened that this was not taken into consideration when throwing down punishment. Yes, I agree there should be consequences, but I feel the consequences could have been more appropriate in teaching the lesson rather than punishing a "crime". Taking for granted that "everyone knows graffiti is wrong" is not a fair way to see things. At least with my kiddos, things and situations arise every day that we have to "talk" about because it doesn't come naturally. You can't fix something like this until you have encountered it- it is part of the package of autism. *hugs to you both* 

kris --- 16 years ago -

BLM the courts are taking it to trial , this was not tried as of yet just had him there for his arranement. When the judge realized the situation that is when he stopped proceedings until a lawyer had the chance to speak with us. We go back in Nov, and the attorney who is representing Seth has assured us that he will fight in higher courts if necessary. Hopefully we don't have too. I mean this is silly how it has been handled , people are quick to judge with out all the facts which was part of the reason I posed this topic, to see if others where open minded enough to see this case for what it was. A lack of understanding , a lack of judgement and a lack of support for kids / families who deal daily with weird or strange behaviors due to delays or challenges. I found it interesting when I posed this topic on another mom forum how people reacted. Did you know that across the US there are currantly 986 cases in city courts pending against special needs people ? Not them as defendants but as accussed? How hard is it to identify these cases when proper channels are not used to aid said people? I thought this would be a great way to educate others here about what it's like when dealing with life's suprises and people like my son. I hope that this opens eyes to situations that should not be allowed to happen, not because it was my son , but that it could have been anyone elses' child on here. Thanks for the feedback everyone :) 

Natalie --- 16 years ago -

I don't know that he actually looked at this as though he was creating the graffiti - rather he was covering up a drawing that was very offensive. I think that is where I see so much wrong in this and the people at that school that know him so well should have taken care of the situation instead of letting an over zealous cop and an academy principle that is on a power trip handle things! Oh yeah, that is MY OPINION (before I am in court)! 

kris --- 16 years ago -

Lol Natalie, I hear you loud and clear. Now for my part I am a proud supportor of our county services, most of them are great guys and gals, as with most of the school personel I have met and worked with in the past. But you know there are always those who want to outshine and such , ok great just get all the facts is my point. And no Seth didn't think of what he did as graffi he honestly just didn't want to see or have others see that picture , so he covered it up with a positive symble :) 

kris --- 16 years ago -

Daisy thank you for better explaining what it's like. And no S is not upset about your comment , it helps him to see how others truely see him and others like him. And it is sad that people really don't get what it's like. But on a positive note, he had a great time at the Autism walk this last weekend in KC and met several other people just like himself, which was a big deal for him. And no one felt odd or out of place, which was cool. Such a rare ablitiy for him now as he gets older. 

daisypetals2000 --- 16 years ago -

But on a positive note, he had a great time at the Autism walk this last weekend in KC and met several other people just like himself, which was a big deal for him. And no one felt odd or out of place, which was cool. Such a rare ablitiy for him now as he gets older.


awesome! Your family and Hope's family are such an inspiration for me - you guys certainly have given me light where the outlook was at one time bleek. I can't thank you guys enough for your insight. 

kris --- 16 years ago -

Lol glad that we can be a light to someone out here lol, KS is sure in the dark at this time of year. All joking aside , it's a big change from when they are smaller to when they are almost grown. You really have to be proactive or they just get lost in the system. Which sucks. Because the older they get , there really is not much to help educate them about life situations they will face. Besides doing waiver programs , group homes , guardianships , etc. I know he will get there eventually but man it is along time a coming it seems. But we all keep trying , ya know :) 

*~Kristle~* --- 16 years ago -

After reading the details, I am sorry that this is happening to you, while I can not relate entirely, I can relate on the level of dealing with someone who isn't on the level that those around him believe he should be. I think that his situation should def. be taken into consideration, it is not his fault he reasons the way that he does, and that in mind it seems to me that he just wanted to correct what had already been done instead of causing more harm. 

Blondie --- 16 years ago -

Graffiti is graffiti no matter what the picture is of, I believe he deserves a punishment, although a lesser one due to his intentions. Definitely not grounds for court IMO. 

kris --- 16 years ago -

TY Kristle, like I said the story is not always what it seems. And Blondie a agree, graffiti is graffiti regardless of what it is, and yes he did deserve a punishment. I never thought he didn't. But I do feel as though given the fact that he did not damage or destrooy the building's wall that the charge they gave him was unfair. There was no criminal intent. And trying a person with such that can not reason why it was criminal damage or destruction , when they even offered to clean up what they had done was to me pointless. If my son had had intent to do damage then he would have actually done it . That is how people like him think. Believe me it's not a gray area with autistics. It's either black or white. Because of people like my son , I am an advocate , a supporter of their families , and help with trying to educate others who don't face or deal with what our families do. Many people on here know my family and know me, I am not a laxed parent. I do hold my children accountable for their actions and behaviors. But like DP said, they do not do as we do because their world is not like ours. How they see things and interact is based on what they preceeve as right and wrong. Reguardless of how much I try to teach him or his brother , he always faces challenges differnt. And some times he suprises me with situations that were not fore seen as being a problem . Example this situation. He has never colored on walls even as a child, he has never been in trouble for damaging other people's property, or possesions. So for anyone who knows my son to be able to predict that he would do anything like this was not realistic. It is out of character for him. But when addressed about it he admitted to doing the smiley because he has been taught to be truthfull. Due to how he processes his choices , he can be upset or "triggered" by things that can lead to "odd" behaviors. This is no different than a person who has sizures due to flashing lights, loud noises, or stress. Or a person who has MR and becomes aggressive . My whole thought about this thread was to understand how as a society we look at a situation and make judgements with out thinking about things that can affect others who are dealing everyday with situations like this. I know back when I was a kid , people like my son were encouraged to be put away , locked in back rooms, and not included in many family functions due to lack of training, fear, or shame. My point was to show that although everyone likes to think we have come a long way from back then , really we haven't. 10 years a go my doctor tried to tell me and my husband that our child would not be capable of living a "normal " adult life. We were told so many things about what to expect with him , but we never gave up. We worked , trained , and educated ourselves , to help him be his best. When the schools he has been through thought we were nuts spending hours going back over leasons with him , we still did it. When he had "meltdowns" we ralleied together as a family to keep going. And when he was bullied and picked on all through grade schools and middle schools we sought out better schools for him. We love him , are not ashamed of him , and just want people to take a moment to think, not all kids do bad things because they are bad. Sometimes and some cases , they think they are doing something to "fix" a problem that they encounter. They like all of our children just want to have a life where they are not "different" , or "wrong " . To often though these kids are not shown a positive way because , society makes rash judgements. Whether you agree or dis agree is fine by me, I am not easily offended. I just wanted to see what my son sees almost everyday, judgement with out reason. I do not mean that disrespectfully, am not directing it at anyone who commented here, just wanted to open eyes about what society really thinks , so I can better prepare my son for his adult life. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
women
news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground