Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Grounding on Halloween

who's talking here?

Southern_Belle 1
Tiffany 4
BadLuckMommy 2
Jennie 1
giffs fam 1
daisypetals2000 5
FreeLittleFootFanClub 1
Kayce 1
~*Kandice*~ 2
Torri 6
Tee C 2
centerofattention 1
Duchess of York 7
lovelylady 1
TTs Neighbor 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Duchess of York --- 16 years ago -

Okay I have a question....my 4 yr. old has been out of control lately with his attitude and temper tantrums. He talks back and just doesn't listen. I am most likely going to ground him from going trick or treating, but wanted some input on wether or not kids should be grounded on holidays. Thanks! 

Kayce --- 16 years ago -

I personally wouldnt because at that age i think its kinda pointless so punish them at a later date for behaviors that are going on now. Maybe you could use the candy he gets and only give him a piece if his behavior that day earns one. Kinda like a reward system. 

centerofattention --- 16 years ago -

I would do it. If you have already told him you were going to ground him from trick or treating then I would do it and make him hand out candy to the ones that are trick or treating. It is the natural consequences of acting a fool. At 4 he knows how you expect him to act, and he is throwing tantrums so he really knows how to get what he wants. You need to be in control now. But I am old school when it comes to punishment. 

Torri --- 16 years ago -

I agree with Kayce. Does the punishment really fit the behavior, and are you punishing him days later? You need to act on that issue at the time of the issue. Believe it or not, giving consquences like that usually had an adverse effect. I would really think about it before you knock Trick or Treating out.

But what you could do is explain to him that you are allowing him to do it and why. And come to an agreement that if his behavior doesn't straighten up he will see himself receiving punishments right on the spot!

Good luck!! 

Tiffany --- 16 years ago -

I have a 4 year old and I couldn't imagine her doing anything so bad I would make her skip trick or treating, and I would never go so far as to make her hand candy out knowing she couldn't go. It's only once a year, is what your child did so bad it's worth another year of waiting?? I would use the candy as stated above to reward good behavior. I think it would have more of an effect on the current behavior. 

Duchess of York --- 16 years ago -

It's not just one thing, Tiffany. This has been going on for awhile. He through a fit friday and didn't wear his costume to his party. I don't want to take halloween away from, I'll get no enjoyment out of it trust me. But I don't think he really deserves to go. I haven't decided yet, I'm going to wait and see how he acts tomorrow, and I guess decide from there. I wanted to go to the pumpkin patch in manhattan today but yet again he had a nasty attitude today so we didn't go. I dunno I guess I'm just incredibly frustrated with his behavior. he gets rewarded when he's good but that's not often. 

daisypetals2000 --- 16 years ago -

Okay... I don't know your son, but I am speaking from my experience as a mother (of 5). Generally speaking, there is a reason for kiddos being onrey little monsters. Could be possibly be tired or hungry? Maybe needing a little more attention? Is dad gone? I know my 4 year old will do all kinds of crazy things to get my attention. She has had moments like this ever since I had the baby a year ago. Maybe he is just testing the boundaries to see how flexible they are. Sometimes getting to the root of the issue is easier than dealing with the ongoing behaviors - I am not saying NOT to discipline, I am saying that if the originating issue is not resolved then the behaviors will continue. I agree with Torri and Kayce - there need to be immediate consequences for misbehavior. Spanking, time-out, loss of reward, loss of something special (toy, tv time, etc)... whatever you use to correct him. I personally would never take away halloween unless we were walking out the door to go trick or treating and the kid was in a complete full meltdown or something of that nature. At that point I would guess it was bedtime and would make sure that happened. I know in our home, we have to evolve discipline and tailor it to each child. When they start acting up and what I am doing isn't working anymore I try something new. We have had LOTS of luck with the positve rewards system. Pretty much what we have is a chart - started out with 5 horizontal boxes. My son and I worked out a reward (ice cream from out, trip to the zoo, chuckecheese - whatever is a good motivator). We drew a picture of that reward at the end of the line of boxes. Each day he was good at school, he would earn a sticker. Any days he misbehaved he didn't. At that point I would simply tell him how sad I was that he was not getting his sticker. If he threw a fit, well he went to his room until he calmed down. I DO NOT GIVE IN. Then when he gets all the stickers we do the reward. Then I increase the number of boxes with each chart. :) Idk if it would work for you or not, but worth a try... 

Torri --- 16 years ago -

Everything Daisy said I agree with! And she is a good Mom with alot of patience! haheha 

daisypetals2000 --- 16 years ago -

awww thx Torri... btw... that chart doesn't work for my kiddos when cleaning their room... lol! HOWEVER... the black trashbag is VERY EFFECTIVE. :) 

Tiffany --- 16 years ago -

Generally speaking, there is a reason for kiddos being onrey little monsters.

I was just thinking the same thing. I agree with punishing, but I also agree with Daisy, I would never take away a holiday unless it was melting point, especially at that young age, now if it were a teenager that would be different. 

Tiffany --- 16 years ago -

I don't want to take halloween away from, I'll get no enjoyment out of it trust me.

If I in any way made it sound like that is what I meant I apologize. It's never easy punishing out kids. 

Tiffany --- 16 years ago -

I really think the trick or treat candy would be a great tool to work with him. He wouldn't have to miss the actual act of trick or treating that they only get once a year, BUT....he would have to earn the candy with good behavior. 

~*Kandice*~ --- 16 years ago -

the black trashbag is VERY EFFECTIVE. :) 

Yes, Yes it is! haha 

daisypetals2000 --- 16 years ago -

BUT....he would have to earn the candy with good behavior.


sounds like a plan. I don't give mine all the candy anyways... they get a couple pieces along with a mug of hot cocoa when we get home. Then they get ready for bed and I eat my candy. LOL! The joys of being a parent. :) 

Jennie --- 16 years ago -

Then they get ready for bed and I eat my candy. LOL! The joys of being a parent. :)


LMAO!!! That is how my parents did and I don't care how selfish this sounds...but I do too! Someone has to check it for stuff ;) 

giffs fam --- 16 years ago -

I wouldnt take halloween away form my kids even tho i have threatened them. but thats more to get them to behaive and to keep their rooms cleaned. And so far it has worked they have behaved latley and kept their rooms cleaned. 

~*Kandice*~ --- 16 years ago -

LMAO!!! That is how my parents did and I don't care how selfish this sounds...but I do too! Someone has to check it for stuff ;) 

Haha yeah I take all the "bad" candy from mine haha. They dont ever notice though haha. 

Torri --- 16 years ago -

Ha mine must be trained!!! lol Everytime we get home they pour their candy out and seperate all of it. Mom's pile, Dad's pile, and our pile...lol

I get all the tootsie rolls, and sour patch kids, Dad gets all the malt candy, and twizzlers. LOL they take the rest!

I did by no means tell the kids they needed to give it to us, they just know what we like, so they share the wealth!

Dont worry kids, Christmas is back on!...lol hahhahahaha 

Tee C --- 16 years ago -

Torri, you probably know your son better than anyone ever could, so you know best how he reacts to certain situations and how effective the punishment will or will not be. You just have to search yourself and if you're sure that taking Halloween away from him will benefit his behavior and attitude in the long run, so be it. I know it is so hard sometimes to make tough decisions as a parent, but it can pay off in the long run. 

FreeLittleFootFanClub --- 16 years ago -

We have threatened it but they always straighten up really quick afterwards. No way would I do it. For one this is the first year my hubs has been home for Halloween for all of them. And those costumes are expensive! Lol. I wouldn't personally because I dont feel it is an appropriate punishment for that age group but every kid is different. When ours miss behave they dont get to go ride there bikes that day. We tell them every day is a new start and they can try again tomorrow to behave enough to get to do it. Its a privilege not a have-to. I think we have only taken them away once or twice. Maybe something like that is a better punishment then taking away trick or treating. Take away something they like to do for the day then start again tomorrow. Or just spend some time with him and ask him what is wrong. IDK about yours but mine will tell me whats wrong most of the time ( like he isnt tired so thats why he didnt take his nap and played instead... that kind of thing... not anything major). Try positive rewards. You could always let him trick or treat them not let him have his candy until he earned it with good behavior. Good Luck 

Duchess of York --- 16 years ago -

Those are all awesome ideas :) But I've tried them lol. They don't work with him. I've taken toys, tv, bike, everything away and tried to make him earn them back. I've done time out, going to his room, spanking as a last resort. NOthing. I remember my 8 year old being somewhat like this when he was younger and he's freaking perfect now lol. So I'm hoping my youngest ends up the same way. I have never taken a holiday or something special like that away, that's why this is such a hard choice to make. I knew what ya meant tiffany :) I didn't take it personally, just wanted to explain that I'm not a mean mom at all but I've had enough of his attitude. His dad is deployed, and we talk about his deployment alot as a family but he does say alot that he misses him. I can completely understand that, and having issues with explaining how he feels since he is only 4 but he has to know there are boundries. Ugh, the joys of parenthood I guess :) 

daisypetals2000 --- 16 years ago -

oh yes.... parenting is a tough job. TOTALLY AGREE THERE. *hugs* 

Torri --- 16 years ago -

Torri, you probably know your son better than anyone ever could, so you know best how he reacts to certain situations and how effective the punishment will or will not be. You just have to search yourself and if you're sure that taking Halloween away from him will benefit his behavior and attitude in the long run, so be it. I know it is so hard sometimes to make tough decisions as a parent, but it can pay off in the long run.


TeeC....Im not the one grounding my child, its someone else. 

Duchess of York --- 16 years ago -

Thanks Daisy :) I swear I could offer him a trip to disney world if he picked up one toy and he still wouldn't do it lol. He's hard headed like his....dad....haha! 

Tee C --- 16 years ago -

TeeC....Im not the one grounding my child, its someone else.

I apologize, Torri; I should have said Michelle.

Michelle, did you decide what you are going to do? 

daisypetals2000 --- 16 years ago -

oh yes... we did that today... cleaned bedrooms. I have no advice there as I ended up getting out the trash bag and putting everything out of place in it. Oh well... rooms are clean. :) 

Duchess of York --- 16 years ago -

I am going to wait until 4:30 tomorrow and see if he doesn't act better. Hopefully he will act right and we can have a fun night as a family. thanks for asking Tee C :) 

BadLuckMommy --- 16 years ago -

I know its a subject that you brought up, but lets say if he doesn't act right and you decide to take away his trick or treating, does that mean your 8 year old is going to stay home too? I don't think 4 is old enough to comprehend what being grounded is. I could tell my 3 year old your grounded, and she'd probably look at me funny because she has no idea what that it. My older two know exactly what it is but they are 7 and 9. I think that taking Halloween away is a little harsh. But thats JMO. 

Torri --- 16 years ago -

Well....did he make it out? 

Duchess of York --- 16 years ago -

BLM, no if my youngest wasn't going trick or treating he would just stand there with me while his brother went to the houses, I'm not going to punish both for one's behavior...but luckily we didn't have to worry about that!! He got to go trick or treating!! Yay lol. He was even good enough that I took them to the pumpkin patch and we all had a blast the entire day. Thanks for asking Torri :) He did really well, he was about done after an hour 1/2, it was just to cold for him. Soooo glad it's over though :) They got a TON of candy and the bowl I had left out was still pretty full when we got back so my oldest got to pass out candy! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground