Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

*SPIN*: How Old is Too Old for Breastfeeding?

who's talking here?

Angie33 2
Hope 2
BadLuckMommy 1
daisypetals2000 1
Penny 1
~*Kandice*~ 2
notsue 1
Tee C 4
Cassi 1
magenta 1
allycat 1
Roxanne 1
lovemyhubby 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

In your opinion, is there an age a mother should stop feeding her child, or do you think it depends on the child'd personal development and shouldn't have a limit? 

~*Kandice*~ --- 15 years ago -

I think when the child goes "Hey mom, milk please" they are too old. I know after 12 months or earlier they should be drinking out of sippy cups so if anything I would pump and put it in a sippy cup if I wanted to continue to breastfeed. 

Roxanne --- 15 years ago -

I think when u feel comfortable that ur baby can drink from a cup just like taking a baby off the bottle yes? 

magenta --- 15 years ago -

my story...and opinion

when i went to the WIC office to rent a breast pump (because i'm producing WAY more milk then what my baby eats) the lactation consultant told me an alternative to freezing it would be to pump it in a cup and give it to my 3yr old cause ANY breast milk at ANY age is good for you (blank stare..lol) and after a moment i said "no way he's been milking the cow since he was 1yrs old and I aint going back down that road with that NIPPLE BITER!"

MY OPINION: Its a free country...just expect stares and A-hole remarks for 2yr olds and above 

Angie33 --- 15 years ago -

IMO, 12 months is as long as I would go with breastfeeding. 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

When I was growing up, there was a kid named "Larry" that lived on the other side of town. Larry was about 8 or 9, and his mother would still breastfeed him. Sometimes, they'd sit on her front porch and do it. I was young at the time but I found it disturbing. There is also a woman in England who breastfeeds her 9 and 12 year old children still. I am all for personal freedom, but not to the detriment of the child. 

Angie33 --- 15 years ago -

^^^Ewww! That sounds like something that would be on the Maury or Tyra show! 

~*Kandice*~ --- 15 years ago -

I know for some its an emotional attachment to their child through breastfeeding. They feel like they will lose that bond if they stop, I personally would want my boobs back and not have leaking boobs for any longer than I have to haha. 

notsue --- 15 years ago -

All three of my children had their bottles mysteriously disappear by the time they turned a year old, so if I had been breastfeeding, thats prolly whre I'd cut that off too. I figure, if I'm able to give them milk now instead of some special formula, then its not gonna kill them to take normal milk now also if I had been breastfeeding instead. But its just me, you do what you want. This isnt advice, just one ladies opinion. 

Hope (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I recently rewatched the movie grownups and the 4 year old breastfeeding boy came to mind ..when he asked to have another womans milk!!


Im all for the nutrition for an infant but if some lil kid is still on the tit and thinks all women disperse milk whenever they are hungry..i think thats a problem. Now that was just a movie but you know there are kids out there who are still being breastfed past crawling age. Also they say pacifiers due to sucking can cause mouth problems ..what about suckling a boob that long..not to mention what it does to the mom...ok just TMI'd myself lol but you get the idea. 

BadLuckMommy --- 15 years ago -

I think 12 months is the age that the child needs to start forming some independance, even with the milk. This is just my opinion. I say to each its own but it is a little akward if you breastfeed a 3-10 year old in public. 

lovemyhubby --- 15 years ago -

in my opinion when they start having teeth its time for me to stop. i really don't want to get bit in the process. lol 

allycat --- 15 years ago -

I think by 14 months the child should be done drinking from the breast at least. Just to help their development. 

Penny --- 15 years ago -

My sister belonged to the Le leche league and she breast fed her kids till they were 4. CRAZY!!! 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

My sister belonged to the Le leche league and she breast fed her kids till they were 4. CRAZY!!!

Okay. I can understand some mothers wanting their child to have breast milk for as long as they can give it to them (because it is very healthy, has been linked to rapid brain development, etc), but why does it have to come directly from the breast when the child is that old? A 4-year-old child with no special needs has enough cognitive ability to be able to identify the breast as being more than for food. At that age, it could also make for some very interesting memories when they are a bit older...

Also, this may be unpopular but I believe that after a certain age, breastfeeding becomes more about the mom than the child. I'm sorry, but after my daughter turned a certain age, the only mouth that came close to my nipples was her dad's. LOL 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

My sister belonged to the Le leche league and she breast fed her kids till they were 4. CRAZY!!!

Okay. I can understand some mothers wanting their child to have breast milk for as long as they can give it to them (because it is very healthy, has been linked to rapid brain development, etc), but why does it have to come directly from the breast when the child is old enough to drink from a cup? A 4-year-old child with no special needs has enough cognitive ability to be able to identify the breast as being more than for food. At that age, it could also make for some very interesting memories when they are a bit older...

Also, this may be unpopular but I believe that after a certain age, breastfeeding becomes more about the mom than the child. I'm sorry, but after my daughter turned a certain age, the only mouth that came close to my nipples was her dad's. LOL 

lovemyhubby --- 15 years ago -

tee c i agree!! lol 

daisypetals2000 --- 15 years ago -

I just wanna say hats off to all of you that have the patience to nurse for extended peroids of time. LOL. My kiddos would never actively nurse so I pumped and gave it to them, but that lasted about 6wks... I have way too much to do to be tied down pumping and then feeding... lol. As far as a *magic* age to stop, I suppose I am agreeing with those around 12mos. I guarantee if mine would have nursed it would have stopped here when the chompers came in. LOL. 

Cassi --- 15 years ago -

There is also a woman in England who breastfeeds her 9 and 12 year old children still. I am all for personal freedom, but not to the detriment of the child.


Exactly. That is far beyond what is needed and I can't imagine what hurt this is doing to the child. 

Hope (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

woman in England who breastfeeds her 9 and 12 year old children still. I am all for personal freedom, but not to the detriment of the child.


that cant be mentally healthy for a middle schooler to be suckling at moms teat..and if there is a man figure in there what the heck kinda relationship is that to find out or deal withthat she has a preteen attached to her breast still 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground