Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

What do you guys think?

who's talking here?

Misty 3
Torri 1
UGrewInMyHeart 1
19Dwifey 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Misty --- 15 years ago -

I read the article below and it made me angry. Why can't people fight for both causes? And why are the animals any less deserving than a child? I guess it just makes me angry because this is the kind of attitude that leads to this kind of severe abuse towards animals. I firmly believe that we should also fight for the children but animals have NO VOICE unless we give it to them! I'm not trying to make anyone upset but after seeing the case this journalist is refering to it makes me angry!

Snoops Story. WARNING! Very disturbing image.


There's a decent chance you've heard about the disturbing case unfolding in Winnebago County right now. It has received quite a bit of publicity in the northeastern part of Wisconsin - indeed, around the globe - and is likely to receive quite a bit more by the time it works its way through the courts.

A dog, a pit bull-mix named Snoop, was found dead on an Oshkosh sidewalk in late March, and its owner, 19-year-old Bryan Hutcherson, has been charged with mistreatment. Hutcherson told police that he stopped feeding the dog because it was stressful and cost too much, according to the complaint. In other words, it is alleged, Snoop starved to death.

An online petition started by a woman in Buffalo, N.Y., is asking that Hutcherson be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. Thousands of people from Portugal to Pennsylvania already have signed it. Hutcherson's face has been on TV. He's in the papers. People all over the world are outraged, and at least some of them are already emailing the district attorney's office to make sure prosecutors don't drop the ball.

Winnebago County Deputy District Attorney Scott Ceman says he hasn't seen a case get this much attention in his area in at least three years.

Do you have any idea how many kids die of child abuse or neglect in Wisconsin in just one year?

In 2009 alone, there were 23, according to the Children's Service Society of Wisconsin. That year in this state, there were also 930 substantiated cases of physical abuse of a child, 1,406 substantiated cases of sexual abuse of a child, 62 substantiated cases of emotional abuse of a child and 2,809 substantiated cases of child neglect.

I was recently alerted to just one alleged case of neglect from that year up in Oconto County, one that hasn't received much - if any - attention. This is National Child Abuse Prevention Month, a good time to change that.

David and Jan Carpenter have been charged with neglect of a little girl they adopted in November 2008. Just shy of 3 years old at the time, she was small, only 23 pounds. Eleven months later, in October 2009, she weighed even less, only 21 pounds - about what a 1-year-old typically weighs. By then, she was almost 4.

A doctor at Children's Hospital of Wisconsin, according to the criminal complaint filed in March 2010 against David Carpenter, told the Oconto County Child Protective Services that the girl looked "like a concentration camp survivor." The child, the doctor indicated in a report, had "no subcutaneous tissue to speak of." She suffered from severe malnutrition, according to the criminal complaint, as well as an unexplained subdural hematoma.

The Oconto County Department of Health and Human Services removed the girl from the care of the Carpenters due to her "severely emaciated condition, her injuries and the lack of medical care or any other support services," according to the complaint.

The prosecutor in the case, Jane Krueger Smith, declined to comment, and David Carpenter's defense attorney, Royce Finne, said it's a "fairly complicated case" that is hard to synopsize in a few sentences. His client, he said, denies any physical abuse of the child and doesn't know how she would have gotten bruised. Finne also said that a plea offer made at one point has been withdrawn.

The case - as well as the one filed against Jan Carpenter - is still working its way through the courts, so we don't know what's ultimately going to happen.

Whatever it is, I sort of doubt it will get much attention, though. Not like it would if the little girl were a dog.

By Mike Nichols 

Torri --- 15 years ago -

Sad and unbelieveable!! In my opinion this creature shouldsuffer the same fate as snoop. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

THAT IS RIDICULOUS! I so agree w/ you Torri!! He should suffer just the same!! He should know how it feels to be left outside to starve! 

Misty --- 15 years ago -

InfantryWife8890 he wasn't left outside to starve. He was placed in a small wire crate in the owner's living room, where for a month they didn't feed him a single crumb or piece of food. They sat there on the couch , probably eating in front of this dog, and watched him starve and dehydrate to death for a month. When he was on death's door the owner walked him 2 blocks down the street and placed him on a sidewalk where he laid overnight in freezing cold temps until someone found him. The sad part is his wife sat by and allowed this and the person who said they saw snoop in february shaking and covered in his own poop also saw this. Why didn't either of them say something to someone? Passive animal abuse and neglect is still animal abuse and neglect!

Torri is right though the man should suffer the EXACT same way this poor dog did! 

19Dwifey --- 15 years ago -

I'm not a dog or pet person AT ALL... but this is just horrible. It makes it worse that THEY went about their business with this dog in their home, starving. Like I said, I dont like dogs, nor do I have one, but I did when I was growing up (he was a feisty thing which is why i'm so scared of them now) but if Mom went out and asked us to feed the dog, and we got caught up in playing or whatnot, within an hour past normal feeding time, our dog would be going crazy barking. I can't imagine days and days. Poor thing must have been so hungry. Both the husband AND wife should be charged. They both allowed it to happen. They could have brought that dog to any shelter or called the cops/animal control if they couldnt afford it.. anything other than letting him die like that :(

But I have to say, why was child abuse brought into this? I almost want to say its offensive to compare mistreatment of an animal to the mistreatment of a child. They are both horrible and both deserve severe punishments because neither is right, but I don't see the correlation between the two. Just the same.. if the original article was about someone who murdered their spouse and then child abuse was brought up. Unless of course it was in the same household, fine that makes sense. Or if the dog owner was also charged with abusing or mistreating a child.. but otherwise, i'm confused as to why both topics are being brought up here. Not being snarky, just wondering if maybe i'm missing part of the story. Animal Cruelty and Child Abuse are two different worlds in my opinion and should be handled that way. Again.. before someone jumps at me.. i'm not saying animal cruelty is ok or not as bad as child abuse, they are just completely unrelated. But again.. my view of it. 

Misty --- 15 years ago -

19DWifey, I don't understand the article either. Basically the guy was saying that there are children being mestreated but people are focusing all their efforts on this poor dog. To me he is saying we should focus our efforts on child abuse rather than wasting time on animal abuse. I agree with you they are two different causes and we as humans have a hear that will guide us to the cause we believe in. 

19Dwifey --- 15 years ago -

Basically the guy was saying that there are children being mestreated but people are focusing all their efforts on this poor dog.

Weird on his part. So this guy thinks that because there is something bad going on with children, we should ignore whats going on with other things? That's like saying we shouldn't focus on children being abused because there are adults being murdered. So not the point! Ugh.. people annoy me! There will always be something worse going on, but that doesn't mean we should ignore the other things. Jerk! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground