Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Calling someone else Dad

who's talking here?

mommyto4 1
notsue 1
Tee C 1
Roxanne 2
austinsmom08 4
LovinLife824 2
HomeNC 2
Dess 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Dess --- 15 years ago -

My husbands daughter lives in Florida for part of the year and with us the other half. Her mother in the past two years has moved in with a man she had a baby with without asking my husband or informing him of it until four months after the fact and lied to him up until them about their address. Now, when my husband talks to his daughter (5 yrs old)on the phone she refers to her mother's borfriend as daddy. My husband tried to discuss with ex how he'd like her to be corrected. Ex wife states it was her choice to do so and she's not going to scold her for calling him that. My husband explained he's not asking for her to get in trouble but would like her not to call someone else dad. Ex wife states it cannot be corrected now without permanently damaging the child... hate to even start drama or an arguement with ex wife because it lasts forever and makes our life miserable. What's your take on the whole calling boyfriend, not step dad, dad?? 

austinsmom08 --- 15 years ago -

My son did that with my now hubby of 2 yrs but he also was 6mo old and is all he knows for a dad since his bio dad is a pos......now had his real dad been in picture then I would of been more hesitant bout it but I see it as he has 2 dads just ones more of a dad then the other now in ur situation ur hubby wants to be part of her life and is active in her life so yes she should get corrected.....u can nicely correct a child and say no not daddy but so n so and it won't damage the child my son has called his uncle dusty daddy few times on accident and we just simply say no dusty and then he says dusty 

HomeNC --- 15 years ago -

Dess no she already has a Dad that to me is a big No No, even calling a Step-Dad Dad has to be talked over with everyone I mean that is a big step but she already has Dad and should not be calling the boyfriend Dad, Damage to the child to tell her to stop calling him Dad, maybe find a nick name for him that is right, Damage to the child is letting her call the boyfriend Dad and he walks out on them that could cause damage to the child. My children do not call my husband Dad and my husband's son does not call me mom they both have a mother and a Dad I am sure you husband is a wonderful Dad my son's father is a dead beat and my Step-Son his mother walked out on both of them when he was a baby so no matter how awful my ex is my son calls his Step-Dad by his name but we all know who the true father is. Okay I wrote a book Sorry. 

Dess --- 15 years ago -

I feel the same. Dad is a special title to me just like mom. As long as mom or dad are there and involved in her life then there shouldn't be an issue of calling boyfriend dad.. it should have never been allowed to start. First we thought it was just slips or accidents but now we know it's not.

HOWEVER in the past two days both conversations my husband has had with ex wife regarding it has been done, without his knowledge, in front of daughter so todays conversation went something like "daddy, why don't you like my other daddy?" and "why does mommy say you don't want me to call him daddy anymore?"
May not be worth it- ex wife seems to be adsent minded when it comes to topics to discuss in front of your kids.... might do more damage raising the issue...??? 

HomeNC --- 15 years ago -

I don't know you are right it should have never been started in the first place. Now the child is put in the middle that is not fair to the child or your husband. Some people just don;t get it. What they need to do is sit down with the child and tell her that she has a Dad and that the boyfriend should be called something else. Be grown up about it, it just is not right. This is a tough one sorry I don't have better advice for you. 

mommyto4 --- 15 years ago -

It depends on howit started and why? Did she start calling him dad on her own or was she told too? Would it be diffrent if they were married? My kids call my husband dad (their step dad) and their real dad nathan. It was there choice we never said one way or the other we did correct them in the begining but as it went on and nathan proved to be a pos and hubby was the dad, father everything we just let it go. Nathan is in another state calls maybe once a month or less and sees them maybe once a year if that so am I wrong for allowing them to call my husband daddy the one that is here for everything in their lives? 

austinsmom08 --- 15 years ago -

Nope mommyto4 ur not wrong......I'm in same situation my son is 3 his bio father has seen him 2 times never calls nothing I get 50 bucks child support that's it my hubby does it all and has been there since my son was 6mo old so he is dad! 

Dess --- 15 years ago -

Every situtation is different. Being dad is more than blood I agree. Thing is my husband is involved and she lives with us part time. I think it breaks his heart more than anything. Anxious to see my step daughter in June and see if she's still acknowledging my husband as her dad... 

notsue --- 15 years ago -

I'd not have worried about it, when the child grows up, he/she will figure things out for themselves. 

austinsmom08 --- 15 years ago -

As the old saying goes biology doesn't make a father, and anyone can be a father it takes someone special to be a daddy! 

LovinLife824 --- 15 years ago -

My husband was/is in the same situation. My stepdaughter is now turning 6 and has been with me, her stepmom, and her stepdad for the same amount of time, about 5 years. She started calling her stepdad dad around 3-4 years old. My husband and I think it was coached by both the mom and stepdad. First he was Derek, then DeDe (which strangely sounds like Daddy) and then Daddy Derek or Daddy Dede then Daddy. That didn't really bother my husband too much, because she spends the school years with her mom and stepdad then the summers with my husband and me. The messed up part was that her mom told her to call my husband Daddy Will, instead of just Daddy, so they would know the difference between the two. Now she is calling her stepdad dad and my husband Daddy Will. This infuriates and hurts my husband. We have had countless conversations with the mother regarding this, because it's just not right, especially when the mother is pushing the names on their daughter. Last summer, we had to explain to my stepdaughter all the parts of her family, ie mom, dad, stepmom and stepdad. She said that she called her stepdad Daddy, because mommy and daddy Derek make fun of her when she calls him Derek. My husband jumped on the phone with her mom after hearing that comment. Last summer my stepdaughter came to me and asked me if it was ok if she called me mom, because I'm her mom when she visits me. I said of course, you can call me whatever you feel comfortable calling me. She calls me mom and by my name, because she has always known me by my name. In that situation I think that is ok. Probably not with her mom, but my stepdaughter approached me and asked. Unlike the situation with her stepdad. 

Roxanne --- 15 years ago -

I think no matter what the situation stepparents and biological parents should have a clear line. Daddy is daddy mommy is mommy and any step parents should be called by their names as they are not the child's parent UNLESS the stepparent adopts the child.But as long as biological parents are a part of the child's life boundaries should be set from the beginning 

austinsmom08 --- 15 years ago -

Well when the bio father wants nothing to do with the child then the step dad should be allowed called dad imo but everyone has own opinions this is another topic ppl will agree to disagree on. My husband plans to adopt my son but either way my sons bio father knows he calls my hubby daddy and he doesn't care cuz he could give 2 shits less bout my kid 

Roxanne --- 15 years ago -

UNLESS the stepparent adopts the child.But as long as biological parents are a part of the child's life boundaries should be set from the beginning  

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

Dess, this is a tough one. I'm sure your husband is very hurt at the thought of his child calling another man "Daddy" (and frankly, I personally concerned with the mother allowing her daughter to call a man she isn't married to by that term).

I could wax poetic and the rights and wrongs of the situation, but I won't. But I'll tell you this (as a child who has been there): Your stepdaughter isn't quite cognizant enough just yet to understand the true meaning of calling mom's boyfriend "Daddy", but she will figure it out one day and she'll be ticked at her mom if she believes she was coerced and used as a pawn. It won't even be when she in her teens; she'll probably "get it" around 8 or so. So tell your husband to keep his head up; the child honestly doesn't know what she's doing. 

LovinLife824 --- 15 years ago -

Your stepdaughter isn't quite cognizant enough just yet to understand the true meaning of calling mom's boyfriend "Daddy", but she will figure it out one day and she'll be ticked at her mom if she believes she was coerced and used as a pawn. It won't even be when she in her teens; she'll probably "get it" around 8 or so. So tell your husband to keep his head up; the child honestly doesn't know what she's doing.

This is extremely true! I went through this growing up. When I was younger I was forced to call my stepdad dad and didn't want to. When I got older I hated my stepdad for it, because as I got to know him as I got older I knew it was him who made that decision for me. I didn't have ill feelings towards my mom though, for other reasons. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground