Here is my issue. And I know nothing can be done about it so dont start bashing automatically. I honestly do not think it is right that full BAH is taken out no matter what rank the soldier is. I dont understand how a private can live in the same housing development as a Sgt or higher and they pay less for the same housing!! There should be a baseline. If your BAH is over the baseline, you should be able to pocket what money is left!!! Just doesnt make sense. Rant over lol
But why does it matter? Who cares what rank the guy next door has. Bottom line is you have a roof over your head, utilities you don't have to worry about having turned off if you cant pay the bill one month, full lawn service you never have to worry about and a clean neighborhood to live in. I live in a beautiful house on post but even if I lived in something that wasn't as nice I would just be thankful I don't have to worry about the usual things you worry about living off post...just MY OPINION.
o I completely agree, it's really frustrating and I feel like they are taking advantage of it. I believe there most defiantly should be a baseline.. Not only would that be fair but I know would help families financially. I know we could really use the extra money, and I know several other families that could too!
If all the neighborhoods on post weren't housing, say there was no military housing what do you think these same homes in these neighborhoods would run? Not including all the utilities?
A whole heck of a lot more than I pay in town. I know with my little crappy apartment and utilities I pay over 900 a month. NOT including my phone, cable and internet
thats exactly what i was asking at the townhall meeting but i didnt really get an answer. Yes it does doll because if a e3 lives besides you and he only get 750 and u are lets say e5, e6 or above you paying 1300-1500 for the SAME house plus you pay utilities too. I think its nice to be picerne because they be making money!!!!!
I personally don't care what rank the person is living next to me, but if it's the same house, everybody should pay the same amount. There should def. be a baseline for it. I'm grateful too for having a roof, but when we moved onto base it costs us the same amount to live on base as it did off base with the rent and utilities, etc. But I agree, should be a set amount for each house, regardless of rank.
It's not just picerne though, it's the same for housing on posts that aren't privatized. In a perfect world it would be nice to have a set "rent" basically for the style house you live in but then it would cause other issues in housing. Right now they have wait lists for the size house you need. You can request a certain neighborhood and could sit on the list for years! If they went thru each neighborhood and determined what rent, in the area, would run for the style and size of house, and neighborhood they are located in how many people would gripe then? People would think some houses are "over priced" and complain about that. Then if housing goes thru the trouble of putting value on the homes they could decide to just have you pay your own utilities other then water and trash like most landlords in the area do. It's a flawed system but right now the way it is is the lesser of two evils the way I look at it.
Oh, then you have to factor in the "exception to policy" people that have medical needs in certain homes. It's kind of like low income housing. Isn't that in some instances based on the income you have or the lack there of? Not everyone in low income housing pays the same amount for their homes.
It's not just picerne though, it's the same for housing on posts that aren't privatized.
Thank you! It has always been like this--even when it wasn't privatized. Heck there used to be a time we had to have permission to live off post. Be grateful, at least now you have a choice.
the thing is doll that you paying double of what your neighbor pays for the same exact house with maybe a child more or the same amount of children it doesnt even matter. The problem is still that the neighborhoods should have different "rents" and you go from there which one you want to choose just like it is off post. You go and find yourself a house if you want a nice one you might have to pay on top of your bah.
I see where you coming from though but i think its still ridiculous that sometimes you pay double of what your neighbor pays for the same house, service and whatever else.
I don't see how it is fair for an e6 in warner trilevels to pay the same as a e6 in a 3bd in forsyth. (Nothing against tose in trilevels... just making a point)... those rooms in the trilevels are tiny and only offer a storage closet rather than a garage... some are in dire need of repair but yet they pay equally as someone in brand new construction? Completely unfair... but what in life is fair? Ugh.
I agree with your rant. This is why housing is SUPPOSE to be broken down into ranks because it has less to do about rank and more to do about the money given for BAH. I could care less about rank but that doesn't mean its right... If they are broken down from E1-E3/E4 and E5-E6 and then E7-up there is less money difference in what they get for BAH. Some posts like Carson break it down even further (E1-E3, E4-E6, E6p-E7, E7-up) But noooo Fort Riley has to be dumb and mix everyone together causing people to pay half what others pay for the same house.
We live in a trilevel and believe me I wish to GOD there was a bench mark. The fact that we are paying $1410 a month for this P.O.S. disgusts me. Before the Army privatized housing if you lived on post you didn't get BAH at all you just got your house. I think there should be seperate housing based on rank. Not because we are better than the E4 living next to us but because my husband has worked hard for the last 8 years and I think there should be some kind of reward for that. I would love to see someone go tell one of the CSM's wives in the single home in Forsyth they don't deserve that nice house because of rank lol. In the civilian world it's the same way. The manager at walmart gets paid more than a cashier and therefore can afford a better home. They should assign the quality of home based on the amount of BAH you receive not just because it's the first open one available. I might sound like a B@!#$ but my husband has put in his time. If the private next to us makes it to becoming an NCO then he needs a new house and hefty pay raise too. Just my opinion.
I look at it this way...We get BAH for a reason...HOUSING! Basic Allowance Housing...not BAH plus play around money/savings/ whatever you would use the extra money for. If they went to changing the amount of the actual housing then the military would start changing the amount they give you.
Stitches- That isn't always an option for people. Seeing that response gets old. People PAY BAH to a housing company and they have the right to voice concerns about their home. You have the same rights as a civilian tenant. On that note if you rent off post should you be able to pocket any extra money you have if your rent is less than your BAH or should DFAS be able to require you to submit the amount of rent and pay you just that much? Just sayin.
Dont complain too much about housing there... Here we pay more then double for a house half the size of our one in Riley. On top of that we have too many dependents in the house ( every room is doubled and with how small the rooms are you cant fit two beds in one room) but would have to pay almost $1400 to move into a bigger house that actually fit you. At least with Picerne the house we lived in was nice and we could have doubled.
11BPrincess- That is a good response. And actually it is a option for almost all people. In the civilian life you actually dont get an amount for housing so basing civilian life against military life is not a good comparison. BAH is not for all the extra you get paid over what you pay for housing, but if you want to go that route then here is what I think about it. You have options...you might not like option B, C, or D. You dont have to like any of the options, but sitting here fighting over a system that is broken to begin with does not make any sense. Everyone has an opinion on what they think about it, but in the end it wont change anything. You have option A of living on post...option B of living off post. Those are the two options.You know what comes with each option and you chose one of them. Stop complaining about a choice that you made.
Actually housing used to be price based on the house you lived in instead of just taking your whole BAH. Then they changed it to based on rank so that the people who were paying more BAH got the nicer houses.
I think BAH shouldnt be based on rank. Just let it be a flat amount that the military thinks is suitable for everyone to survive on. When you go up in rank and want nicer stuff, or have more kids you can go ahead and pay for it yourself.
ACTUALLY Stitches-There are jobs where you get a housing stipend in the civilian world. But six in one half dozen in the other. While moving off post may be the option for most it is not an option for everyone. Some people have to live on post because they can't afford first and last plus deposit, or other things involved in living off post or because they can't afford transportation and living on post is closest to their job. You can't make a blanketed judgement unless you can say you know most all peoples financial situation which you do not. I am not complaining about anything and neither was any one else. We were stating something about a policy we don't like. Which we have just as much right to do as the people who tell us to shut up and live off post. If I hadn't been living in a hotel for two months with my husband and two small children due to the army's incompetance I would have made a choice to live off post, however we felt that it was more important to take the house that they offered us upon arrival than continue living in a hotel. You don't know everyone's situation so automatically assume everyone is in the majority.
Here's my thing- I think if you live on post, then you have a home and thats the end of it. If you live off post, you get your money and do with it what you please. However, I don't think Picerne should be collecting all the extra money. In my opinion, they should determine how much a home is worth rent-wise and regardless of the soldiers rank, that is all Picerne should get. I dont think the excess should be handed to the soldier, but I don't think Picerne should be making sometimes DOUBLE rent off higher ranked soldiers. If it's a home that is designated for E3's.. then Picerne should get whatever an E3's BAH is monthly. When that E3 gets promoted and their BAH goes up, well Picerne should still only get what they determined the housing was worth for the E3.
I understand the frustration, but it's not Picerne that sets the BAH. It is set by the Depaetment of Defense. They are only allowed to charge what a soldier's BAH is, no more no less.
Thats right scienceqt its not picerne but picerne put all that money in their pocket!!!! Instead of making neighborhoods based on a certain amount of money which you have to pay monthly of course its better to just make houses and put everybody in there so you pay lets say 1500 for a 30 years old house while others pay 750 for a 3 years old house. But this is a neverending discussion