Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Some Hoarders Are The Most Selfish People In The World

who's talking here?

Misty 1
Tee C 5
Michelle84 1
lovelylady 2
CHHL 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

I'm watching Hoarders right now because I can't sleep, and--Lord help me--but I want to smack the living piss out of the episode's subject tonight.

She--quite literally--has 6 feet of junk and trash piled up inside every room in her house and had to move to an apartment because of it, but she refuses to listen to her daughter or any sort of reason. She actually said--and I quote, "You can't tell me to just throw anything out because I won't listen; you can suggest, you can educate, but you can't demand." Nice.

Some people have mental disorders that stem from abuse that lead to hoarding (and I understand that), but I don't beleive that is the case for most hoarders; I think most of them are lazy slobs who think their need to keep things outweighs the greater good. If I had my way, the city she lives in would take that home, attack it with shovels, gut it down to the drywall and resell it to a hardworking family who will renovate and appreciate it. Selfish! 

Michelle84 --- 15 years ago -

I agree. I watched one that they said he hoards trash....I was like no he doesn't pick up after himself. I have seen real hoarders and they did need counseling, but the ones that have a bunch of trash and are worried about losing their kids might just need a reality check. 

Misty --- 15 years ago -

Some people have mental disorders that stem from abuse that lead to hoarding (and I understand that), but I don't beleive that is the case for most hoarders; I think most of them are lazy slobs who think their need to keep things outweighs the greater good.

While I agree this may be the case with a few people, I have also watched that show...a lot and I think it is truly a mental disorder. Those people have attachments to trash...that is not normal! I have an attachment to my thing but I would never cry and breakdown over someone throwing away a box of trash like those people do! 

CHHL --- 15 years ago -

I do not think it is selfishness. I believe it to be a disease process,, it can be based on anything from abuse to the loss of a loved one. And I can't believe one would advocate the city taking someone's property and reselling it to someone else because they do not like the way they live. Wow. I guess all alcoholics and drug addicts or anyone with a disease should watch out because one does not like their disease and we can have the city swoop down and give their property to someone they feel may appreciate it more. 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

I do not think it is selfishness. I believe it to be a disease process,, it can be based on anything from abuse to the loss of a loved one. And I can't believe one would advocate the city taking someone's property and reselling it to someone else because they do not like the way they live. Wow. I guess all alcoholics and drug addicts or anyone with a disease should watch out because one does not like their disease and we can have the city swoop down and give their property to someone they feel may appreciate it more.

I advocate whatever means necessary to correct those individuals who live in such a way that it is detrimental to the health of the community. Cities and towns step in and pursue actions of condemnation and removal from properties on hoarders because--private property or no--there are certain health standards that must be followed, even inside one's home. That is why I made the comment about the city stepping in and taking the woman in question's property.

Autonomy goes out the window when your front yard looks like a landfill and rats and other vermin begin to infest a neighborhood because someone has garbage piled up 6 feet to the ceiling in every room of their home. I certainly wouldn't want to live near that stench, even if the owner "doesn't mind". 

CHHL --- 15 years ago -

But you put forth above these people were selfish and did not appreciate what they had and since they did not it should be taken away and given to another.

I don't think the owner 'does not mind' the mess but they are too sick to recognize what they have done. You only mentioned a mess in the home in your post not outside. If she has a mess outside too then that is where the city can fine her to get that up to par.

She needs help like those with an addiction IMO. 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

But you put forth above these people were selfish and did not appreciate what they had and since they did not it should be taken away and given to another.

Yes, and I stand behind that statement about some hoarders being selfish. For many of them, the only mental disorder they have is "Too Stubborn To Listen To Reason-itis". In cases (where they refuse help and end up violating health codes), I absolutely believe the city or town should take their home; laws and policies are in place to help those who cannot or will not help themselves.
I don't think the owner 'does not mind' the mess but they are too sick to recognize what they have done. You only mentioned a mess in the home in your post not outside.
Have you ever lived near a hoarder? I have, and I can assure you that the smells that eminate from their homes isn't merely contained to the inside of their dwelling. If only it were. I know firsthand that it drifts outside and affects the quality of living for others on the street.

If she has a mess outside too then that is where the city can fine her to get that up to par.
Health and Welfare can step in if a house if filthy inside as well, whether there are children involved or not.

She needs help like those with an addiction IMO.
I agree that those with an actual disorder need help. But if you watch the show, you'll see that the majority of the hoarders 1) refuse any sort of paid-in-advance aftercare, 2) the only reason that they even consent to accept cleaning assistance in the first place is because they are threatened either by the city or their relatives with legal intervention and 3) only end up parting with very little; it normally ends up going to a storage shed or getting shifted to another dedicated "junk room" in their home. 

lovelylady --- 15 years ago -

Unfortunatly I have way too much experience in the subject of hoarding :( My mom is a hoarder and I mean big time, YES just like on the show, only its not trash or anything its just stuff, but still TONS of it, there is barely a path to get into the house, just a tiny area on the bed to sleep & thats it, can't sit anywhere, etc...the outside is just as bad & the van well don't even go there lol...she can barely sit in it. I don't feel that she is selfish, just doesn't see things clearly, I really almost feel bad cuz most the stuff she gets she says is for my kids but then we don't get it or can't use it, etc...she is a yard sale/freebie/thrift store junkie & loves buying things...anyway I guess I got off topic but I can totally relate & have to deal with what the show does in real life :( 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

Unfortunatly I have way too much experience in the subject of hoarding :( My mom is a hoarder and I mean big time, YES just like on the show, only its not trash or anything its just stuff, but still TONS of it, there is barely a path to get into the house, just a tiny area on the bed to sleep & thats it, can't sit anywhere, etc...the outside is just as bad & the van well don't even go there lol...she can barely sit in it. I don't feel that she is selfish, just doesn't see things clearly, I really almost feel bad cuz most the stuff she gets she says is for my kids but then we don't get it or can't use it, etc...she is a yard sale/freebie/thrift store junkie & loves buying things...anyway I guess I got off topic but I can totally relate & have to deal with what the show does in real life :(

welovekstate29, I am very sorry to hear that. We had a packrat in our family who teetered back and forth with being a hoarder, and it was just sad what her sons and daughter went through when she passed.

If I may ask, have you ever offered her help? If so, what was her response? My cousins had to threaten to call Health & Welfare on my aunt because it was the only way they could get her to listen to them about clearing out the items in her home. When they finally were able to get in and clean she didn't keep it that way, and sadly my oldest cousin (her oldest son) found out after she passed that she had 4--yes, 4--12X12 storage units on the west side packed to the brim with items. He found out after he found the leases among her things. Just really sad all around. 

CHHL --- 15 years ago -

I agree that those with an actual disorder need help. But if you watch the show, you'll see that the majority of the hoarders 1) refuse any sort of paid-in-advance aftercare


As do drug addicts and alcoholics, and many with mental diseases-- refusal to take medication and see doctors. I guess some could paint them as selfish—but I see them as sick.

As far as the city making her clean up her home—that is much different from taking her home and giving it to another family as you suggested. It is a slippery slope. If we do such for hoarders then one could argue that the drug addict and the alcoholic also endanger neighbors but in different manners. 

lovelylady --- 15 years ago -

Tee C, thank you. Yes we offer her help all the time...funny thing is she will ASK for it, BUT when you get there its another story, you can't get rid or anything. Now I like stuff too (just not a hoarder lol) so I don't make her just throw things away, but like once we found a nasty gross shoe & I threw it away right? She went out in the dumster & got it out because "the other one was there somewhere" I mean she just can't get rid of things...but they gripes & complains that there is stuff everywhere & its our fault (the kids) for not helping its just sad :( 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

Tee C, thank you. Yes we offer her help all the time...funny thing is she will ASK for it, BUT when you get there its another story, you can't get rid or anything. Now I like stuff too (just not a hoarder lol) so I don't make her just throw things away, but like once we found a nasty gross shoe & I threw it away right? She went out in the dumster & got it out because "the other one was there somewhere" I mean she just can't get rid of things...but they gripes & complains that there is stuff everywhere & its our fault (the kids) for not helping its just sad :(

My aunt did the same thing. She would kvetch at my cousins about how they wouldn't "help" her, but when they'd show up with their sleeves rolled up she'd panic and get defensive. She'd use whatever means necessary to retain her items--whether it was guilt, bullying, temper tantrums, storming off, or just plain bad behavior.

I am not a psychologist, but with the Psychology classes I had to take for undergrad I firmly believe that hoarding is deeply rooted in some form of a narcissistic disorder--and that's why I originally alluded to "selfishness". Hoarding eventually becomes less about the things and more about, "Well, it's mine and I'm going to keep it no matter what and you can't tell me what to do with my items, no matter how it affects someone else."

It took my cousins nearly a year to get my aunt's house together after she passed--about 3 months for the full cleanup and then another 9 months or so to get all the repairs done to make it liveable again. She had so many things piled up in a room on the 2nd floor that it had weakened some of the floor joists, but boy, you just couldn't tell her she was a hoarder. She'd get offended and say she was too clean to be a hoarder, that she was a packrat.

Sorry about the long post. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground