Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

The Trayvon Martin Tragedy

who's talking here?

Penny Lane 4
Hope 4
proud wife of a retiree 2
notsue 11
Tee C 10
Gemini09 1
Roxanne 1
UGrewInMyHeart 28
CHHL 21
JPaint21 1
BadgeBoy 2
Silverkitten 1
Misanthropist 1
Isis 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

Has anyone followed this? As the mother of a 16-year-old, I am still in shock with the whole ordeal. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

I have been. What ever colors of people involved, I do not care. I dont think it should be so easy to shoot someone. I dont want to take anyones guns away, but if you shoot someone, I want someone to take a good long look at it before they let you run back home to a normal life. Killing is serious stuff. 

Isis --- 14 years ago -

I have since it happened, its absolutely appalling that this.....guy....is still walking around with his freedom after he murdered this child. And as for Geraldo saying that his (Trayvon's) hoodie was partly to blame for his death, that fool is irrelevant and doesn't need to be paid attention to. 

Isis --- 14 years ago -

Zimmerman said he felt threatened by Trayvon. He was 17, Zimmerman 26? is was in the car following him....How are you threatened by someone but yet your follow them around in your vehicle then get out and confront and murder them? 

Hope (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I think more facts need to come about. I think the media is putting out some false info to incite emotions. I think it takes time for an investigation to get to the truth and patience is needed for justice. A lynch mob will not serve justice-- people need to let the officials tell the facts before people let their emotions take over and put a bounty on peoples head with no one saying anything because they feel wronged. It is horrible that a teen was killed. If he is guilty he deserves what he gets in a trial with the facts presented- not in the public eye with speculation and emotional distress from a tragedy.

I have faith that officials will do their job and the truth will come out 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

I have faith that officials will do their job and the truth will come out

If it weren't for past cases, I would have the same mindset. All the evidence can lead right to the defendant and the jury can / will still find them "not guilty". 

Hope (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Its true a jury dont have the experience that those who do law enforcement do and a lawyer can turn and twist things to confuse and make doubt in a jury. But I think the cops and officials should do their jobs and not be swayed by politics nor media for a certain outcome and just seek justice for whomever since they are putting the investigation together ..not the media. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

@Hope - I definitely agree with you. Not to go off subject, but there sure is one case I can think of at the snap of a finger that DEFINITELY wasn't swayed by the media: Casey Anthony. Not to stir up a discussion about that, but as a lot of people know ALMOST the whole country (I did say almost lol) thought / still thinks she is guilty...we all know the outcome of that though :( 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

I can concede that in the age of Facebook, many people "jump on the bandwagon" (so to speak) when it comes to certain "causes du'jour"--oftentimes without doing the proper research before taking a stance. In this case, however, I don't believe that is the case.

Many of the people who are so outraged at what happened to Trayvon Martin wouldn't have even been aware of him being killed if George Zimmerman had been arrested after the shooting. This case would not have made the national news, it would not have every media outlet from Fox to CNN to the BBC discussing it--and the President of the United States certainly wouldn't have commented on it. It would have been a local story, tucked away under someone's byline in a regional newspaper.

But the fact remains that Mr. Zimmerman wasn't arrested after he shot Trayvon Martin.

The irony is that if I could somehow get into a time machine, travel 2 years into the future, and see that Mr. Zimmerman was acquitted of murder I don't think that would surprise me. But a man pursues (and shoots) a 17-year-old child and isn't even arrested--when even a bag of marijuana in Florida will at least get you a trip to the slammer and a ticket? Wow...

I am the mother of a 16-year-old daughter. She is a geek. She loves video games, anime, playing her clarinet, drawing mangas, and triple-decker peanut butter sandwiches. She also loves to wear hoodies. And it grieves me deeply to think that she could visit a relative, go to the store, buy a bag of Skittles and a can of iced tea, get followed, accosted and shot to death by a grown man--and then her shooter wouldn't even be arrested. If I was Trayvon Martin's mother, I would feel that the Florida police were telling me that my child's life didn't matter. 

Isis --- 14 years ago -

The 911 call

He was told not to follow the kid, and if you listen to the tape he KNEW that the guy he was following was a teen. IMO he stalked this child, he went out looking for trouble. He said Trayvon ran while he was following him, I would've ran too!! At night, minding my business walking home from a store and someone is following me in a car, damn right I would run. He should have left it to the REAL police and Trayvon would still be alive. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

I'm really angered at the people in the media saying that George Zimmerman is somehow a victim in this whole ordeal. Since when is the victim the killer? Since when is the aggressor the victim?

I cannot throw a rock at someone, have them throw a rock back at me in return, then throw another rock at them and claim the second rock was an act of self-defense. Since when are people allowed to follow strangers, then claim they hurt the stranger because they were afraid for their lives? Usually when a person is afraid of someone, they don't aggressively follow them in a car and then get out of the car to confront them. I'm so angered that certain news organizations really believe reasonable people enjoy having their intelligence insulted. 

CHHL --- 14 years ago -

Zimmerman said he felt threatened by Trayvon. He was 17, Zimmerman 26? is was in the car following him....How are you threatened by someone but yet your follow them around in your vehicle then get out and confront and murder them?


I think we need to hear all the details before making a judgement. Zimmerman was an idiot for not listening.

As far as his feeling intimidated he would not know Trayvons age, Zimmerman is 5'8" inches tall and Trayvon was 6'3".

There are witnesses who state that Trayvon was beating the snot out of Zimmerman ( not saying he did not ask for it) but we have only heard one side of this story. 

Isis --- 14 years ago -

The 911 call did it for me, he pursued Trayvon, he was the agressor IMO. Now their trying to say that Trayvon went for the gun, well the gun would have had to been pulled on him or out in Zimmerman's hand in order for Trayvon to "go for the gun". There is no justifying the murder of an unarmed man, and if Trayvon was on him beating the snot out of him he did deserve it, because if Zimmerman would have stayed his behind in his car like he was told to we wouldn't be having this coversation. Mary Cutcher told Dateline that she and her roommate both saw Zimmerman "straddling the body, basically a foot on both sides of Trayvon's body, and his hands pressed on his back."

Cutcher added that Zimmerman told her and her roommate to call the police.

"Zimmerman never turned him over or tried to help him or CPR or anything," Cutcher said.Witness statement 

CHHL --- 14 years ago -

There is no justifying the murder of an unarmed man, and if Trayvon was on him beating the snot out of him he did deserve it, because if Zimmerman would have stayed his behind in his car like he was told to we wouldn't be having this coversation


I agree he was an idiot, period. However he did not listen and got out of the car and followed. Just because he was an idiot does not mean he can't defend himself once he is in a situation where he is now fearing for his life and being beaten, how would Zimmerman know he was unarmed.

AGAIN, I disagree with what Zimmerman did and I think it is a disgrace what happened and truly feel for this boy and his parents. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

I agree he was an idiot, period. However he did not listen and got out of the car and followed. Just because he was an idiot does not mean he can't defend himself once he is in a situation where he is now fearing for his life and being beaten, how would Zimmerman know he was unarmed.

I keep reading that George Zimmerman "feared for his life". How does a reasonable person act if he fears for his life? Does he follow the person of whom he is in fear? Does he put himself in a situation where they "confront" a stranger? All signs point to "no". "Self-defense" intimates defending oneself from being attacked; how can one be both victim and aggressor? They can't. That is, unless they're trying to beat a murder rap.

Why would George Zimmerman get into a physical alternation with someone of whom he was afraid? Could it be, perhaps, because he knew that he was armed and could fire if he chose to do so? If the beating was as severe as has been mentioned in the media, why wasn't he sent for medical attention?

Florida Title XLVI, Chapter 0776, particularly Statute 776.032 is the law being debated in this instance. Statute 776.012 of Chapter 0776 (Use of force in defense of person) is the law many have referenced vis-a-vis the Trayvon Martion ordeal--and it just does not apply. It clearly states, "A person is justified in using force, except deadly force, against another when and to the extent that the person reasonably believes that such conduct is necessary to defend himself or herself or another against the other’s imminent use of unlawful force. However, a person is justified in the use of deadly force and does not have a duty to retreat if if:
(1) He or she reasonably believes that such force is necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the imminent commission of a forcible felony; or
(2) Under those circumstances permitted pursuant to s. 776.013 (which covers home invasion).

Under some people's reasoning, if you confront me on the street, we get into a physical altercation and you shoot me dead? It's my fault because you felt threatened. Come on--there is no way a person can be that vapid unless it's convenient for them. According to Orlando Attorney John H. Gutmatcher, who is very pro Stand Your Ground, "If you do use a firearm or other deadly weapon – the law gets complicated, and you may not be acting legally unless you are trying to stop a forcible felony. Under any circumstance, the use of force must be reasonable, and the degree of force used should not be excessive. Using excessive force can be a crime, and even a felony. Forget their ages; forget their races; forget their builds or appearances; is it unreasonable to expect someone who isn't a trained law enforcement officer to not take it upon themselves to play vigilante? All the talk of the "what-ifs" sets my teeth on edge, because at the end of the day Trayvon Martin is still dead and George Zimmerman is alive and free. It isn't unreasonable to expect that the man should have at the very minimum been arrested for taking someone's life. 

Hope (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

it just seems most have made up their minds already and the investigation is still going so regardless of what comes out it will be used or twisted to fit a persons conclusion that they already have.

I can point out that it was a small gated community and he was the leader of the neighborhood watch. so if he saw someone unfamiliar and was alerted that they were someone he didn't recognize he might have been trying to find out who he was so he followed. after that who knows what was said between the two that caused it to escalate the events that unfolded.


he never should of followed. Zimmerman was taken in and questioned and released by the police. obviously the cops had what they needed and not enough to charge at that time but its still an open case. The media had put so much pressure on the police chief that he resigned over a law he has no control over and a bounty is on a man and no one thinks its wrong...i'm just upset over all the events going on and how people who don't know half the facts are making demands on something they don't even know the whole story of. and yes today more came out and tomorrow more will come out. whats said or done can not be undone to the families of both. And the chance that a trial with unbiased people in that state if it does go to trial is rare as most will have their own agendas or fear of reprecussions.

Its a horrible situation but thats florida law. if you dont agree with it and how it was handled -it is still the law of where it happened. Im not a florida resident so Im not going to tell those who live there that they are wrong for something that passed in their state.

I am trying to see both sides but its not shown that yet in the media that Ive saw so far and I am going to reserve judgement til the investigation closes and the officials layout what exactly happened from the evidence and not speculation or media bias.

prayers for both families as they deal with whats to come. 

Hope (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I guess, I am a little discouraged by some of the comments I have seen over the last few days on different social sites and such. Its hard to see the hate and hypocrisy that is being put out there from all sides. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

I just don't get this guy...The person on the 911 phone call CLEARLY told him NOT to follow the guy, so what's he do? He follows him anyway. 

Isis --- 14 years ago -

Well said Tee C! 

Isis --- 14 years ago -

I have in-laws who live a few blocks from where the gated community is (not minority), the things they tell me about the police department...is a shame. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

Self defense or not, any other time the suspect would be arrested. If it was "self-defense", then I'm curious as to where the gun / weapon disappeared to that the victim (Trayvon - the ACTUAL victim) had?
Come on, obviously the police heard the 911 call where the person told Zimmerman to NOT follow him, but he still did so I'm still lost on where the "self-defense" is. Sorry if someone's following someone (male or female, no matter the race) I'd say the self-defense would be on the side of the person being followed. Did Zimmerman or the police find ANYTHING at all on the victim (Trayvon) such as supplies to break into a home, weapon, etc? How can someone not walk through a neighborhood without being a "suspect" for a crime. Ridiculous. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

http://www.thedailyunion.net/newsdetail.asp?article_id=12010

ZIMMERMAN'S THE VICTIM AND MARTIN'S THE AGGRESSOR HUH?! Hmmm, just because you're "neighborhood watch" doesn't give you the right to follow a human being in a car, then get out of your car and follow him...even AFTER the 911 operator told YOU NOT TO FOLLOW HIM! So, because someone you are following gets scared and DEFENDS HIMSELF you claim SELF DEFENSE because he hit you...so you shoot and kill him?! YOUR WORD AGAINST A DEAD TEENAGER...GOOD JOB ZIMMERMAN. This man doesn't get an ounce of sympathy from me, he's still alive and walking (and probably still following people, who knows who he'll kill next). I guess maybe a second "self-defense death" will open the eyes of the police. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Seriously... you are not a victim if you called the police while following someone and the police tell you to quit it and that they are on their way. IMO, you messed up big time when you kill the person before they show up... just doesnt look good when you put the phone call into the equation. I dont get it. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

@notsue- exactly!! I agree with you. I'm so lost how the police aren't doing much of anything about it, as you said, with the 911 call. It's quite funny what the daily union's says about the 911 call in their article: "voices are heard are not clear." Sounds pretty darn clear to me: "Are you following him?" "Yeah".... "Okay, we don't need you to do that!" ... "What's your first name sir?" "George" "What's your last name sir?" "Zimmerman" ......... Hmm, he wouldn't give the operator an address where he is sitting at at the exact time, so he went on to say have them call me and I'll tell them where I'm at...hmm sounds SUSPICIOUS, EH?! They said NOT TO FOLLOW HIM, so why would he even leave from where he was at the end of the phone call, since he didn't give them his exact address to have them meet him at his home. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, anyone who thinks the call isnt clear is just trying to blow smoke up your well... yeah. 

proud wife of a retiree --- 14 years ago -

IMO he was neighborhood watch... does that not mean to be observant and report? 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, anyone who thinks the call isnt clear is just trying to blow smoke up your well... yeah.

exactly!

IMO he was neighborhood watch... does that not mean to be observant and report?

You hit the nail on the head - REPORT...not FOLLOW (as the operator said NOT to do). 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Thats all hes supposed to do is observe and report. Not to get involved and most certainly to not be armed. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

He has 40 something recent calls to 911, and of the 6 they played, all were the same thing... another call about a black guy who looks like hes up to no good. If the neighborhood is that bad, something should be done. Theres no reason for someone to have to call 911 40+ times... how about patrols get increased. Or is he just calling every time a black man walks by? I dunno. I cannot judge that since 6 out of 40+ isnt enough to make that assumption. 

proud wife of a retiree --- 14 years ago -

This is just my opinion, and others may disagree with me, which is fine, each to their own... but if this gentleman had just done what he was supposed to do, and observe and report and nothing else, then this would not even be in the news cause he would not have shot the teenager. He should have left it at that and let the police handle it... 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground