Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Give me a break

who's talking here?

91B Wife 1
BusyMama 1
Tee C 1
Texas Tornado 1
LovinLife824 1
UGrewInMyHeart 1
Silverkitten 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Silverkitten (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

http://www.myfoxphoenix.com/story/18650702/2012/05/29/8-year-old-receives-catastrophe-award-from-teacher

I am so sick of people having a fit over dumb things like this. I had teachers do things like this when I was a kid. It's all in good fun and won't screw the kid up for life. This is no more embarrassing than spilling your lunch tray in front of the whole school. Now that the whole world knows about it (Thanks to the parents) it's probably far more embarrassing. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

It sure is different. I've never heard of a teacher doing something like that. Honestly, I'm not sure what to think about it. I always see both sides to everything (well w/ a few exceptions lol) and this I definitely do. The girl could have prevented getting an award like that by actually doing her homework or her mother or both parents could have helped her; I'm sure the parents were notified of their daughter not getting homework done. Then again, I a teacher knows about bullying and to present this award in class and it only takes common sense to know that the other kids in the class would laugh and poke fun at her. In the end, I see both sides of it, but not sure which I'm in favor of...very interesting situation though. 

LovinLife824 --- 14 years ago -

I read this article this morning with disappointment. That parent is more concerned about this award than she was with her daughter's homework all school year. That parent should be embarrassed. 

BusyMama --- 14 years ago -

I think it was in bad taste on the teacher's part (whether she claims it's a joke or not) but also that mother is either very naive or dumb to think she is not to blame herself. I always ask my kids if they have homework and check their backpacks. I also communicate with the teachers. As parents, we have to stay on top of things and not always blame someone else. 

Texas Tornado --- 14 years ago -

i got an award when i was 8 yr old,,

we graduated and i won the likes to talk alot award i was so proud lol i still have it as well lol.. i showed my mom and shes like yup thats for sure lol..all in good fun 

91B Wife --- 14 years ago -

I agree that the parent should be concerned about her child not turning in homework. However for a teacher to do that, I am sorry but it is wrong and I don't care for it. What is this world turning to?!?! 

Silverkitten (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Texas Tornado I got an award for "moist emproved speling" (I still suck as spelling). It was all in good fun and not a big deal. My mom and dad knew about it and thought it was cute as well. My friends got awards for "Quiet as a mouse" and "Least likely to stop talking." Not a big deal. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

I personally wouldn't have done that to one of my students. Just not my MO. Every teacher has a different style (and normally, that's the mark of a devoted, good teacher) but whether what she did was right or wrong, I personally think it was in poor taste to do it in front of the class. I can tell you right now that my department administrator would have written my butt up if I'd done something like that, lol.

Also, I think there are 2 separate issues here--the child's homework issues and the teacher's handling of the matter. I can tell you firsthand that I met a lot of fellow teachers who were not creative or brave enough (if you will) to deal with problem students. Those are the sort of teachers who resort to group punishment (such as keeping an entire class after school for one problem student's actions in an attempt to get the class to 'bully' the child into being obedient), or outright embarrassment of the child to 'shame' them into compliance. It's a quick fix and frankly, it's lazy. If the only motivational tool I had as an educator was embarrassment, I would have quit as soon as I stepped foot into a classroom.

IMO, right or wrong, the teacher set herself up for this kind of scrutiny; there are so many things that parents can pick teachers apart for, so I chose to not give them any other reasons, lol. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground