Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Do you agree with this?

who's talking here?

BadLuckMommy 1
notsue 3
Tee C 1
Gemini09 3
Garbage Vulture 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

So, someone posted this somewhere else where there are a lot of first time Moms.

A couple people expressed their disagreement with it, and the person who posted it go defensive.

Do you agree with this?

Personally, I think it goes a little far in some parts, and would make a first time mom worry more than needed. We need to take care of ourselves before we can take care of baby.

[i]12 Things your Crying Baby Wants you to Know

1. I am not crying to make your life more difficult. I am crying because something is wrong. Even if it does not seem like it.

2. I am brand new. I do not have control of my nervous system. I am disorganized. Being with you; hearing your heartbeat, smelling your scentÂ… it calms me. It helps me.

3. The fact that I cannot stop crying is not your fault. I know you are doing your best. We are just getting to know each other. We will get there- please stick with me. Please do not leave me. Please keep trying.

4. You are my world. You are my everything. You are all that I know. I do not have anybody else that can provide for me what you can.

5. I do not need to cry. It does not exercise my lungs, or provide any other benefit.

6. The stress chemicals that are released when I cry (that stay with me my whole life) are lessened when you hold me while I cry.

7. Please nurse me. No matter how much I ask for it. Forget the watch or how tired you are. If nursing helps me to stop crying, please nurse me.

8. Do not listen to anybody else. Not your neighbor, not your aunt. Forget the book that you read which talked about helping me to learn to self soothe. Just listen to me. And you. Forget the world outside of ours.

9. I cannot self soothe. It is not possible. If I stop crying when you leave me alone, it is because I have given up hope that you will comfort me.

10. If you at your breaking point ask for help; with the dishes, the laundry and preparing meals. If I am content with somebody else, please use that time to shower or change or have a cup of tea.

11. I know this stuff is hard to hear. We live in a world that promotes political correctness at the expense of others. My needs are real, and I really need you. No matter how tired or fed up you are. No matter how dirty your hair is, or how your stomach growls from hunger. I am your baby. You are my mother.

12. This will not last forever. It feels like it now because we are in this time warp of newbornhood. If you comfort me now, I will be calmer sooner. We will be closer. This time will end- this is not the rest of your life. While you may never long for the crying, your wiser self will be grateful to know that you trusted me and yourself from the very beginning.

Most importantly, I love you Mom. Thank you for trying so hard and taking such good care of me.[/i] 

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

I don't know why the italic is not working.... 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

If we are talking about a newborn, then yeah, it needs something or is hurting and you just havent figured it out yet. Even later tho, at like 3 years of age, the crying usually can be traced back to some misunderstanding. Tho of course all kids are different and I only have experience with my own and others that were close to me so I cannot for certain speak for every child. More often than not, I will be able to figure out why a baby is crying when someone else may have given up and chalked it up as "some kids just like to cry". Do I think any harm is being done by letting it cry after you cannot figure out the issue? More often than not, no... The kid will eventually learn that you dont understand them and will stop crying for whatever the reason was unless its super bad pain that it cannot ignore. 

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

9. I cannot self soothe. It is not possible. If I stop crying when you leave me alone, it is because I have given up hope that you will comfort me.

That is the one that really gets to me.
If you need a few minutes to yourself because the baby is stressing you out and you can't get help. It doesn't hurt to even let a newborn cry for just a few minutes to get yourself together, or if you are in the car, and can't pull over. Do you know what I mean?

I think this could have been put together with more tact, but I get the point it was trying to make. First time Moms may not though. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Yes, its a little harsh. I have no issue with taking a break from the crying... babies/kids crying causes stress to a person. That stress turns into bad things if you let it and thats often where abuse starts. So yeah, take a break and try again in a few, or if it stops crying it doesnt hurt to go give the child some love anyway. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

I think this is probably geared towards the kinds of mothers who would be crazy/unstable enough to shake their babies because they're crying.

I could see a normally nurturing, caring mother being offended by some of this. If you love your baby with all your heart, why would you want to be made to feel wrong because sometimes their crying gets on your nerves?

Also, it's contradictory. I don't need to cry, but I cry because it's my way of communicating. Well, genius, then the baby does need to cry, lol. 

Garbage Vulture --- 14 years ago -

I was rocking my baby back and forth once and got scolded by a lady who said "You should never shake a baby" 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Should have shook the woman and then asked if she noticed a difference between that and what you were doing with your child. 

BadLuckMommy --- 14 years ago -

I don't think it is harsh. There is no instruction manual for babies, its something you have to figure out along the way. It is part of being a parent. I don't agree with the self soothing part though. My doctor told me that letting a baby cry for a minute or two builds their lungs. Being a parent is very demanding and I think this gives people thinking about having kids some insight to what their lives will be like with a newborn. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

women
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground